As the Utah Mine Safety Commission considers all its options before making recommendations to the governor prior to the start of the Legislature, some high-powered mining executives have voiced strong opposition to the creation of a state mine-safety agency.

Three presidents of Utah coal mine operators testified before the commission during a meeting Thursday at the state Capitol. Among their chief comments to the panel was their opposition to the state developing a mine-safety agency that they believe would duplicate much of the work already being done by the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration.

"The state should enhance training for miners; they should enhance the technology at the universities to address the specific geologic problems unique to Utah," said J. Brett Harvey, president and chief executive of Consol Energy Inc., which owns the Emery Mine near Provo. "But to just add inspection doesn't make any sense."

He said the state would be better off developing programs that provide training and education to miners so that they can examine on-the-job safety issues first-hand.

"Empower them to change the safety of the mines as they do their jobs, rather than have some agency who shows up once a week," he said.

Harvey said he respects the work that the MSHA inspectors do.

"The MSHA inspectors are Utah miners; they're the best in the business," he said. "I'm not negative about what they do. I'd rather have those guys in my mine with the federal organization and the technical backup rather than a state organization that's not funded as well."

Harvey testified along with Neil Getzelman, president of Interwest Mining Co., which operates the Deer Creek Mine near Huntington, and Gene DiClaudio, president of Canyon Fuel Co., which operates three underground coal mines in Utah.

Both Getzelman and DiClaudio echoed the sentiments voiced by Harvey.

"It is unnecessary and premature to re-establish the Utah state mine-safety program," Getzelman said.

Of the 17 states with underground mining operations, Utah is among seven with no state safety inspection programs for coal mines. For the past 30 years, Utah has instead turned over safety regulations and enforcement to MSHA.

"A Utah mine-safety enforcement program would only duplicate the existing federal regulatory process," DiClaudio said. He added that some Eastern states such as West Virginia and Kentucky have their own state agencies but still have a higher rate of mine injuries than Utah.