From Deseret News archives:
High court: Barzee to be forcibly medicated
Friday, the Utah Supreme Court issued its opinion that 3rd District Judge Judith Atherton's ruling allowing forced medication will stand. The state's high court voted 3-2 in favor of upholding Atherton's ruling in a 52-page opinion. Chief Justice Christine M. Durham and Justice Ronald E. Nehring dissented.
Barzee, 62, and her estranged husband, co-defendant Brian David Mitchell, are charged with kidnapping and sexually assaulting Smart in 2002. Three times she has been ruled incompetent to stand trial. Doctors at the Utah State Hospital say they have tried everything to restore her competency except anti-psychotic medication, which she refuses to take.
On June 21, 2006, Atherton ruled Barzee met the four criteria set in Sell v. United States and could be forcibly medicated. Barzee's defense team quickly filed an appeal with the state's highest court, which agreed to hear the case on Dec. 6, 2006. Attorney Scott Williams argued that Atherton's decision was not supported by the evidence presented in court.
• Important governmental interests were at stake.
• Involuntary medication would significantly further those interests by being "substantially likely" to restore the defendant's competency.
• The medication would substantially unlikely have side effects.
• Anti-psychotic medication is medically appropriate.
Both Durham and Nehring believed the second point, that anti-psychotic medication would make it "substantially likely" that Barzee's competency would be restored, was not supported by the evidence presented in court.
"I believe the district court did not properly weigh all of the evidence presented within the framework of this high burden. Instead, the court ignored the testimony of the defense experts," Durham wrote in her opinion. "Proper balancing does not simply require a court to pick one expert or one side to defer to ... "
Durham noted that she "did not doubt that medication is the appropriate medical treatment for Ms. Barzee." She went on to write, however, that, "This court is not charged with determining what is best for Ms. Barzee from a mental health standpoint ... Unless the State's interest is highly likely to be furthered by the intrusion upon Ms. Barzee's liberty, this court cannot allow the State to forcibly medicate her ... "
Recent comments
Green light? Like this is some kind of business zoning story, or an...
Bad choice of terms | Dec. 14, 2007 at 5:34 p.m.
Wanda is looking at life in prison for what she helped her husband do...
Lacee | Dec. 14, 2007 at 4:38 p.m.
Isn't it cheaper to keep her in the State hospital than in prison?...
John | Dec. 14, 2007 at 4:17 p.m.
- Dixie campus briefs 1:10 a.m.
- Westminster campus briefs 1:09 a.m.
- UVU campus briefs 1:07 a.m.
- Utah Utes campus briefs 1:07 a.m.
- Visit to paradise nightmarish for Ags 12:32 a.m.
- Utes struggling to shake starts 12:31 a.m.
- Cougars' execution flawless 12:30 a.m.
- Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings 12:17 a.m.
- 3A football: Tigers pull away 12:12 a.m.
- Editorial: 'Immigrant' children needy 12:12 a.m.
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
207 - Dirk does dirty work in Dallas
190 - Lobo suspended
171 - Speed has never been BYU's game
136 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
128 - House passes health care bill
111 - RSL rallies to advance
102 - Prep football: San Juan vs. S. Sevier
102 - Thousands protest health bill
100 - Provo company innovating engines
98
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
NASA's Stardust probe continues to bring new knowledge about the nature...
Nothing proposed would keep young adults from learning of the reality of sex,...
the only "decent" team we played we lost to? I guess that Air Force isn't a...
I am watching the game again, and it is awesome!!!
I can't help but laugh inside when I read comments from YBU/TCU fans who...
(from the independant) I like Dennis Miller.... and Bill Maher, although I...
As a BYU alumnus, I can't justify to myself ever donating another dollar to...
Not a chance. Don't get me wrong they are both studs, but if Asiata wasn't...
Titan Fan, sorry that some of your best players got hurt. I hope they...
So sad how fear based so many are.
Will the Jazz even make the playoffs this year. The way they are playing it...

