From Deseret News archives:
Water suit sent to state court
Roosevelt is trying to add existing well to its culinary supply
On Nov. 28, Judge Tena Campbell rejected a motion by the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs to dismiss Roosevelt city's lawsuit against Utah State Engineer Jerry Olds. The city is suing Olds over his denial of a point-of-diversion application that would have allowed Roosevelt to add an existing but formerly unused well to its culinary water system.
Attorneys for the city and the state had opposed the BIA's motion to dismiss in federal court, which was filed under the umbrella of the Sovereign Immunity Act.
"What they (the BIA) were doing was using their sovereign immunity as a sword, when they were supposed to be using it as a shield," said David Wright, an attorney who represents Roosevelt.
While a dismissal of the case in federal court would have forever ended the suit against Olds, he did not approve of the BIA's methods, according to Assistant Utah Attorney General Norman Johnson.
"The state engineer believes de novo judicial review is part of the water rights application process," Johnson said. "Those aggrieved by his decisions are entitled to such review and that review should be in state court."
However, the BIA was never a target of the lawsuit and the Ute Indian Tribe was merely named as a "party of interest" in the suit against Olds because along with 31 individuals living in the Neola area the tribe had objected to the state issuing a permit to Roosevelt. The opposing parties alleged that the city's development of the well would harm other water users by draining the area's aquifer.
Johnson argued before Campbell that the Sovereign Immunity Act was only meant to shield foreign governments from being sued in federal courts, not as a tool for interfering with the actions of other agencies. He reasoned that the Ute Tribe can still sue in state court if it believes it would be harmed by Roosevelt's use of the Durigan Springs well.
Other federal agencies have successfully used the Sovereign Immunity Act many times in the past 30 years to block lawsuits affecting their interests, according to both Johnson and Wright.
Comments
- Clinton to Dems: pass health bill 12:55 p.m.
- Deseret Book moves from Orem mall 12:52 p.m.
- Ed chief wants to redo appointment 12:50 p.m.
- No bail for accused cop shooter 12:48 p.m.
- Flu appointment full in 15 minutes 12:47 p.m.
- Dodd: Gov't can prevent crash 12:46 p.m.
- Lessons from nutrition conference 11:56 a.m.
- Strategy over outcome in TCU-Utah 11:56 a.m.
- How to pick an exercise class 11:55 a.m.
- Thing looking up for Utah small biz 11:53 a.m.
- Utah group finds homes for orphans
- Senators want food tax restored
- Jazz blow big lead, hang on
- Soccer MVPs know how to win
- Y. tight ends talented tandem
- Utes get extra motivation
- Alta's Ohai is Ms. Soccer 2009
- Pratt pleads not guilty to sex charges
- Price injured; Miles has cast removed
- Mitchell seeks to block witnesses
- House passes health care bill
242 - TCU showdown has big implications
185 - Lobo suspended
182 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
155 - Senators want food tax restored
134 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
131 - Thousands protest health bill
120 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
119 - No 'backlash' for pioneers, gays analogy
104 - RSL rallies to advance
103
Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar restaurants nationwide will honor...
Meghan McCain, the daughter of former presidential candidate John...
Actually soccer is labeled a Contact sport! you are allowed to shoulder...
My grandma's brother had to go and pick up all the body parts of the people...
So if, before you moved in, your potential roommates told you that they were...
Y'all just wait and then use the phrases, "Beyond a shadow of a doubt" &...
The criminality of the incident may be in question, but Pratt's judgment is...
look at the video of the byu ponytail girl taking down the unm goalie while...
You must have a sad, pathetic life.
RedShirt -- Please tell us all again how you concluded that the Good...
In terms of global temperatures, the hottest 11 years on record have occurred...
I am currently working on a Bachelor's Degree from Penn State University that...



You can be the first to comment on this story.