From Deseret News archives:

Man without a country

Dream is citizenship, documentation — and a future

Published: Monday, Nov. 12, 2007 12:35 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
John Garman's dream might not seem like much. But for someone who has spent nearly a decade struggling to prove his nationality, the possibility of being able to hold a valid Utah ID is priceless.

"I'm working under the table," said Garman, who for years has lived essentially without a country. "I don't have a life outside of keeping my head above water."

Garman, 33, was adopted by an American family as a child. Yet he hasn't been eligible to apply for citizenship because of a felony conviction at age 18 for a string of burglaries. And he has no official record of his actual birth. His only photo identification is his prison ID.

For years, the only evidence Garman has had of his birth was a delayed registration of birth — issued in Merced County, Calif., when he was adopted — which said he was born in Tijuana, Mexico. But that was never verified, according to the Merced County Human Services Agency.

"Because of this error, the minor is a person without a country. He is unable to obtain citizenship in any country at this time," the agency said in a petition filed in court last year, seeking to remove Tijuana from Garman's record.

The statement could be true, since in order to prove Mexican citizenship he would need a document issued in that country, according to the Salt Lake Mexican Consulate.

Story continues below
But all that is set to change. As a result of Garman's petition, the California Department of Public Health is issuing him a new delayed birth registration, which shows Livingston, Calif., as Garman's birth place.

He hopes to be able to use that to get a valid Social Security number and with it an American identity.

"My situation makes me unique, it makes me who I am," he says. "If I survived this long, imagine what I can do with a Social Security number."

But even with the new birth certificate, Garman says his troubles aren't over. He's facing a misdemeanor domestic violence charge after an alleged altercation with his now ex-girlfriend.

He worries now that after losing so much time, he could lose even more. If convicted, he faces up to six months in jail and a fine up to $1,000.

"I did seven years (incarcerated), and that scared me enough, realizing that's time wasted," he says. "I've been doing this for (another) eight years. My life's gone. I don't want to lose any more of it."

Recent comments

There is no reason to feel sorry for him. His main issue is proving...

SH | March 7, 2008 at 8:39 a.m.

I have a simple question, as I don't live in SLC. Is there no bus...

Mary | Nov. 12, 2007 at 10:36 p.m.

I'm all for punishing those guilty of crimes, but the punishment...

Future Prosecutor | Nov. 12, 2007 at 9:50 p.m.

Image

John Garman moves a resident's belongings to a new apartment as part of his job. He has no Social Security number.

previousnext

Latest comments

Mathews helps play some defense

I have not been this excited for a long time. This kid is the real deal. What...

Press loves Sarah Palin

Of course you know that Obama is the president and that it only follows that...

Unfortunately neither modern conservative politics nor modern liberal...

Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing

Why don't they write the books? They write plenty. And they study, discuss,...

Student convicted of murder in Italy

I'm not saying the judgement was correct or incorrect in this case. I simply...

You need to re-visit basic sicentific concepts. Using the term "just a...

Nutty Putty Cave to be sealed today

Total strawman argument. I have no doubt that John would have wanted people...

Utahn aiding poor

We wish you well Louis! Thanks for all of the wonderful things you've done...

I agree.. He had that deer in headlights look. He is in a tough spot....

Jared, come on, Wikipedia? Are you serious? Be a journalist. If this was a...

Advertisements