From Deseret News archives:

Utah voucher war shows progressives need new label

Published: Thursday, Nov. 1, 2007 12:03 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — In today's political taxonomy, "progressives" are rebranded liberals, dodging the damage they did to their old label. Perhaps their most injurious idea — injurious to themselves and public schools — was the forced busing of (mostly other people's) children to engineer "racial balance" in public schools. Soon, liberals will need a third label if people notice what "progressives" are up to in Utah.

There, teachers unions, whose idea of progress is preservation of the status quo, are waging an expensive and meretricious campaign to overturn the right of parents to choose among competing schools, public and private, for the best education for their children.

In balloting more important to the nation than most of next year's elections will be, Utahns next week will decide by referendum whether to retain or jettison the nation's broadest school-choice program. Passed last February, the Parent Choice in Education Act would make a voucher available to any public-school child who transfers to a private school and to current private-school children from low-income families. Opponents of school choice reflexively rushed to force a referendum on the new law, which is suspended pending the vote.

Story continues below
The vouchers would vary in value from $500 to $3,000, depending on household income. The teachers unions' usual argument against school choice programs is that they drain money from public education. But the vouchers are funded by general revenues, not the two sources of public school funds, which are local property taxes and the Uniform School Fund. And every Utah voucher increases funds available for public education. Here is how:

Utah spends more than $7,500 per public school pupil ($3,000 more than the average private school tuition). The average voucher will be for less than $2,000. So every voucher that is used — by parents willing to receive $2,000 rather than $7,500 of government support for the education of their child — will save Utah taxpayers an average of $5,500. And because the vouchers are paid from general revenues, the departed pupil's $7,500 stays in the public school system.

Furthermore, booming Utah, which has about 540,000 public-school pupils and the nation's largest class sizes, expects to have at least 150,000 more than that a decade from now. By empowering parents to choose private alternatives, the voucher program will save Utah taxpayers millions of dollars in school construction expenses.

Recent comments

This is about choice. Parents can choose better than teachers where...

Tyler | Nov. 5, 2007 at 1:06 a.m.

George Will is part of the neoconservative movement that has...

Who's calling the shots. | Nov. 4, 2007 at 8:23 a.m.

To whom does the administration administer?
To serve whom and for...

To missing the point | Nov. 2, 2007 at 1:54 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Y is going to dominate the conference for a long time coming. And finally do...

once again that sophmore for the titans is doing work i just don't think...

Non-BCS schools not given fair shot

Your right. Every other sport at every level from 5 year olds to...

i agree w/you that when both are full strength that okurs way better than...

Ranking the bowl games

Winners: Texas, BSU, Oregon St and the Golden Bears. Sweet

Hall doesn't read this stuff but it sure bugged him for a year...even though...

I watched Susan grown up. She is responsible and thoughtful. Susan, your...

Max Hall wants to look ahead

Better have a back up job. NFL doesn't look that promising.

The National championship in college football doesn't always produce a true...

jeff, you said: 'there is no such thing as a "patriotic lib" ' We could...

Advertisements