From Deseret News archives:

Tech cases critical, Roberts says at Y.

Published: Wednesday, Oct. 24, 2007 12:30 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
PROVO — Brigham Young University students peppered U.S. Chief Justice John Roberts with questions Tuesday after he spoke before 7,080 people in the Marriott Center.

Roberts declined to answer hot-button questions about Guantanamo Bay detainees, gay marriage, Roe v. Wade, religion and political candidates such as Mitt Romney and some aspects of privacy law. He said judicial ethics forbade him from doing so because related cases may come before the court in the near future and because judges avoid political debates.

But other questions led Roberts to criticize the use of international precedent by some justices and to reveal his belief that technology-related cases could be the most important area of law considered by the Supreme Court over the next quarter of a century.

Just 52 years old and the youngest chief justice since 1801, Roberts is expected to preside over the court throughout that time.

Emerging technologies can create new questions about old laws. For example, imaging technology exists that allows law enforcement officers to see through walls. "Is that an unlimited search and seizure?" Roberts asked.

Story continues below
"People tend to be focused on what are the hot issues right now," he added. "Those are not the issues I think 25 years from now will be the ones people will look back on and say were significant."

Roberts strongly asserted his belief that U.S. judges should not use precedents established by international courts.

"When we look at domestic precedent, it narrows the authority of a judge," he said. "When we look at international precedent, it expands the authority of a judge. As one judge said, 'It's like looking out over a crowd and picking out your friends.'"

International relations major Evan Crockett asked Roberts about moral principles and whether the Supreme Court plays a role in foreign policy.

"I don't make moral decisions," Roberts said. "I make legal decisions. Sometimes, and even often, those legal decisions are contrary to the judgment I would make were it my job to shape policy, which is often guided by moral principles.

"Our constitutional decisions do have ramifications on foreign policies. That's not part of our job description ... but we are tasked to decide cases that involve the Constitution and involve both the granting authority in the area of foreign affairs to the president in some instances and to the legislature and also limitations on that."

Recent comments

Those of us with part-time CAMPUS jobs couldn't get off work to...

Anonymous | Oct. 29, 2007 at 6:16 p.m.

Disgusted that Idahoan is glad a Bush political appointee is more...

Disgusted | Oct. 25, 2007 at 10:31 a.m.

I am a BYU student and certainly wished to have been in attendance....

SRS | Oct. 25, 2007 at 12:22 a.m.

Image

Chief Justice John Roberts speaks at BYU. He urged the 7,080 present to read the Constitution.

previousnext

Latest comments

Ask just women of childbearing age do they want to decide their reproductive...

Letters: Say heck, not gosh

On behalf of the millions of people worldwide who worship the devine and...

That happened approximately 9 years ago.

Can BYU throw vs. Air Force?

For being a terrible program, Bronco still has one more win than Kyle...go...

3A: Juan Diego wins title

wow, that was a game. #56 for Hurricane seemed to be in on almost every...

That was the most amazing drive and play I have ever seen in high school...

Huntsman blasts media over trip

for stepping up and doing the right thing in challenging portions of the...

A majority of us are apposed to abortion, but we are in even greater...

"Speed kills. Speed beats size everytime. " haha, everytime eh? If that...

Can BYU throw vs. Air Force?

Air Force 35 BYU 21

Advertisements