From Deseret News archives:

Roberts says judges' freedom has limits

Published: Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2007 1:27 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
PROVO — U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts outlined his conservative judicial philosophy during a speech today at Brigham Young University, saying judges should not legislate from the bench.

"The judicial branch has the authority to interpret the Constitution because it is law," he said, "and must be independent to do so without fear or favor. But the judges must limit themselves to that task. They may not use their independence to write their own policy preferences into the Constitution."

During a 34-minute speech, Roberts quoted fellow conservatives Ronald Reagan, twice, and Robert Bork, once, and also used the Federalist Papers frequently to bolster his theory of a critical, but limited, role for judges.

Roberts suggested to the University Forum audience of 7,080 gathered in BYU's Marriott Center that they read the Constitution again and read the Federalist Papers, where, he said, Alexander Hamilton describes an independence for a Supreme Court justice that "is not the freedom to do whatever he pleases."

Roberts spent the first 20 minutes of his talk delivering a basic outline of the first three articles of the Constitution, which describe the separation of powers among the president, Congress and the Supreme Court.

Story continues below
The speech was free and open to the public. Roberts was not paid to appear. The audience gave him a 30-second standing ovation after his address.

After a short break, Roberts fielded 18 questions from BYU students and alumni for 39 minutes. He declined to answer questions about Guantanamo detainees, gay marriage and some aspects of privacy law because cases related to those subjects may come before the court.

He also avoided a question about presidential candidate Mitt Romney, saying he needed to steer clear of political debate.

But he did provide compelling answers to a number of wide-ranging questions about fellow Justice Clarence Thomas (he is not as reserved in private as he is during oral arguments before the Court), the use of international precedent by some justices (Roberts criticized it) and modern technology.

"I think some of the more difficult issues this court will be asked to address is the impact of modern technology on legal issues," Roberts said.

For example, imaging technology exists that can allow law enforcement officers to see through walls.

"Is that an unlimited search and seizure?" Roberts asked.

"People tend to be focused on what are the hot issues right now," he added. "Those are not the issues I think 25 years from now are the ones people will look back on and say were significant."

Roberts also was meeting with a group of BYU law students this afternoon.


E-mail: twalch@desnews.com

Recent comments

The attendance figure also didn't count the places on campus where...

Tiago | Oct. 24, 2007 at 8:01 p.m.

judges should not legislate period like earl warren did among others...

tom | Oct. 24, 2007 at 10:08 a.m.

Anyone can watch the forum at http://byu.tv on demand for free.

NF | Oct. 23, 2007 at 11:58 p.m.

Image

U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts answers questions from BYU students after he gave a forum address on campus Tuesday.

previousnext

Latest comments

BYU eager for crack at Oregon State

Where is Maxi Hall? Did he get invited?

U.N. climate conference opens

The UN just needs to be disbanded or moved outside the US. The buildings and...

Ranking the bowl games

Try Bowl ChickenS. The SEC was scared stiff that TCU would beat Alabama and...

Ranking the bowl games

There is no suspension on the outcome. You know that BYU will lose the...

Letters: Huckabee is lying

He's good. Therefore, what he does must be good. I always thought that that...

TCU versus BSU unpopular

Though the game should be exciting, it is a joke!

the rest of the schools in utah also need campus repairs. The U already gets...

Letters: Global warming a lie

"By not changeing to sustainable zero polution energy you are condemming your...

You Obama lovers voted for an "idea." An "idea" that is not working nor...

Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing

Having lived through the Winds of Hope and Change in the 1960's in Afrrica...

Advertisements