From Deseret News archives:

GOP voucher foes speak out

Published: Friday, Oct. 19, 2007 12:24 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Republican lawmakers who oppose vouchers spoke out Thursday about the "myth" that vouchers will reduce class sizes and help fund enrollment growth and urged voters to read the impartial voter-information pamphlet before casting their ballots.

The press conference on Thursday came after two others on Wednesday that were held by Democrats who oppose the voucher program and Republican legislative leadership who support Referendum 1.

"I respectfully disagree with my Republican colleagues who support the flawed voucher law," said Rep. Sheryl Allen, R-Bountiful. "Utah voters, especially Republican voters, need to hear from Republican lawmakers that this law has too many flaws and will cost too much money — money that could be spent in our public schools."

Utah's Republican-controlled Legislature created a voucher program earlier this year that gives parents $500 to $3,000 per child, depending on income, to use on tuition at a private school. But voucher opponents gathered enough signatures to suspend the program before any vouchers were issued.

While GOP lawmakers who support vouchers urged voters to read the two bills that could establish the voucher program, Allen said she also wants citizens to read the impartial voter information packet that "describes the costs and so-called savings associated with Referendum 1."

Story continues below
"It clearly demonstrates that, as the program is phased in, the costs far exceed any savings associated with the program," Allen said. "Over a 13-year period, Referendum 1 would cost the state $429 million, which is hundreds of millions of dollars more than even the most optimistic estimate of savings."

The lawmakers also disputed recent statements that vouchers stave off enormous tax increases to fund Utah's rapid enrollment growth in the coming decade.

"We have funded education in the state through our entire history, through the Depression and thick and thin," said Rep. Kay McIff, R-Richfield. "Now we find ourselves with the fewest numbers of kids per family and the strongest economy in our state's history and they are saying, 'We can't afford to fund our kids' education'... Citizens should know that we will continue to educate our kids in the state (in a system) that gives us the biggest bang for our buck."

Rep. Steve Mascaro, R-West Jordan, also said he wanted to dispel the myth that vouchers will lower Utah's large class sizes.

"If you reduce the number of students in a school, then you reduce the number of teachers as well. ... Vouchers will not change that," Mascaro said.

The Legislative Fiscal Analyst estimates a reduction of three students, at most, per school per year, he said.

Recent comments

To Representative Allen...RINO..republican in name only....The public...

Adam Smith | Oct. 22, 2007 at 10:01 p.m.

Andy, although you deserve a voucher, you would not get one under the...

Karl | Oct. 22, 2007 at 3:25 p.m.

My 6 year old son went to Public School last year and his teacher...

Andy | Oct. 21, 2007 at 3:54 p.m.

Image

Rep. Sheryl Allen displays anti-voucher charts with other GOP lawmakers, including Rep. Kay McIff, left, and Rep. Steve Mascaro.

previousnext

Latest comments

3A: Juan Diego wins title

so proud of you H town boys. we cant ask for better. as for not being back...

Great pictures! I was there and got some pretty good ones, but the your...

Letters: Say heck, not gosh

Part of the point of saying "gosh" is to avoid vain repetition of the name of...

Cougars cruise to victory in Hawaii

A well deserved accomplishment for a terrific coach. And doing it in...

It's a small Mormon world

The hour is late and I'm not very bright, but I don't understand your post at...

Broncos make Aggies pay

I thought the Aggies were in the game until the end of the 2nd quarter. A...

Broncos make Aggies pay

Sorry to break the news to you, but Boise State really is not that good....

UH guard Hiram Thompson is LDS and an RM and the older brother of freshman...

as bland as wonder bread.

I agree totally with you. I've had some time in the strips and when i was at...

Advertisements