From Deseret News archives:
Fix NCLB or junk it
By now it should be painfully obvious that cookie-cutter education reform doesn't work. It makes little sense to hold schools in tiny rural and remote communities to the same standards as inner-city schools in the nation's largest cities. As a measure of accountability, what is achieved by labeling a school as a failure when it missed the mark on one of 40 benchmarks?
What does accountability mean, anyway, when some school districts avail themselves to appeals processes and others do not, presumably because they don't know how to play the game?
At the same time, it is true that NCLB has pressured many schools that have had long histories of poor academic achievement to perform better and to do more to meet the needs of students. While many education leaders decry the heavy hand of NCLB, are they willing to impose accountability measures that reward the very best educators and the most improved academic performances yet impose penalties when schools under-perform? Will they address teachers who are ineffective?
If not, perhaps NCLB or a law like it serves a purpose. If Congress elects to keep it, it needs to take a realistic look at the vast differences in the nation's public school systems. Can a single accountability measurement take into account differences in school funding, school readiness or location? Should Piute High School, a small, rural school, be assessed in the same manner as an inner-city school in Detroit? Isn't measuring student progress over time a more logical benchmark than snapshots derived from high-stakes tests?
As much as this page has struggled with the notion of federal oversight of public schools and in many respects, continues to do so the bottom line is this: How would the states fill the accountability vacuum if NCLB was to sunset? Until a workable substitute is developed, there may be some rationale for reauthorizing NCLB.
Recent comments
Accountability: Nice analogy! You illustrate why we have to be...
Joe Moe | Oct. 12, 2007 at 1:33 p.m.
Picture this. A man goes into a doctor for a condition. The doctor...
Accountability | Oct. 12, 2007 at 12:19 p.m.
I think I am with you Joe. The system needs to address ALL of the...
j | Oct. 12, 2007 at 11:41 a.m.
- NHL roundup: Ovechkin set to return 11:23 p.m.
- Darts defense again one of 5A's best 11:18 p.m.
- High school sports: Preps of the week 11:16 p.m.
- Endangered fish released in river 11:15 p.m.
- Ogden Canyon closed Saturday 11:14 p.m.
- Drive-by shooting injures teenager 11:14 p.m.
- Kinasewich has tools for success 11:13 p.m.
- Post office named W. Hazen Hillyard 11:13 p.m.
- Lawmaker warns of budget shortfall 11:09 p.m.
- Fewer H1N1 cases reported in S.L. 11:09 p.m.
- MWC expand? Get rid of deadweight
- Relieved Cougs prep for Falcons
- Wounded Utes limp home
- Jazz rookies had to grow up quickly
- Big games keep UHSAA coffers full
- Barzee is expected to plead guilty
- Sloan misses practice
- RSL surprised by Chicago's Fire
- Low in vit. D? Beware heart disease
- Jazz notes: Young bigs ride bench
- TCU creams U.
233 - BYU happy to escape with victory
232 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights
226 - Will state consider gay rights law?
162 - RSL heads to MLS title game
134 - Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?
133 - MWC expand? Get rid of deadweight
122 - TCU stays 4th in AP; Y. 19th, U. 23rd
115 - 5A: Bingham rolls to title game
108 - Bennett at center of GOP storm
89
I was a bit under the weather last week, which gave me some time to...
Hopefully Aggie Fans will fill the stadium, and it can have the spectrum effect.
I don't think this story is meant to be inspiring. I think it is real life,...
To: Your insight please 6:44 These were not new ideas. They were Greek and...
"Dude, you should be home, taking care of business." Please, NOOOO! let...
A prior posting mentioned cheerleading was supported by football/basketball...
Take the quiz at PoliticalCompass Where are you on the graph?
Considering their huge salaries for being a coach, I think Bronco and Kyle...
we will crush you hurricane crush you
Can you imagine how bad the LES field would look after 2 days of high school...
Very interesting story, I can't believe Mr. McNeil got away with everything...

