From Deseret News archives:

Utah gets a bang for its federal tax buck

Published: Wednesday, Oct. 10, 2007 12:34 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — The federal government's system of taxing and spending works out well for people in states like New Mexico, Mississippi and West Virginia — and Utah.

Not so well for those in Delaware, Minnesota and New Jersey.

New Mexico received $3.10 in federal spending for every tax dollar the state sent to Washington in 2005 — more than any other state — according to an Associated Press analysis of new federal data.

Delaware fared the worst, receiving just 42 cents for every tax dollar sent to Washington. It was followed closely by Minnesota, which got 46 cents, and New Jersey, 57 cents.

Utah was on the plus side: The state received $1.27 in federal spending for every tax dollar sent to Washington. For every $4,677 in federal taxes per Utahn that were sent to Washington, the state received $5,952 per person in federal spending.

In all, 30 states and the District of Columbia received more money from the federal government than they paid in federal taxes.

No wonder there's a federal budget deficit.

"I don't get all worked up that Minnesota only gets 46 cents back. I get worked up about the lack of accountability," said Lynn Reed, executive director of the Minnesota Taxpayers Association, which advocates for a more transparent tax system.

Story continues below
"You could write into law that every state should get at least 80 cents back, but that's dumb," he said. "It's inefficient."

The Census Bureau released its annual report on 2005 spending by the federal government Tuesday. It documents the geographic distribution of $2.3 trillion in government spending, including salaries, grants, military pay, government contracts and Social Security payments. It excludes interest on the national debt, overseas spending and the classified budgets of intelligence agencies.

The AP compared the census data to previously released IRS figures for 2005 federal tax collections. The IRS data includes individual, corporate and excise taxes.

The analysis shows that wealthy states pay more than poor ones, blue states subsidize red states, and states with powerful politicians on key House and Senate committees fare well in federal spending.

High-income states like New Jersey, Connecticut and Massachusetts paid more in taxes than they received in federal spending, while low-income states like Mississippi, West Virginia and Alabama got a much higher return for their tax dollars.

The exceptions were Alaska, Hawaii, Virginia and Maryland — high-income states that also received high levels of government spending.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Celtics crush Jazz

What a great night. THe knicks and Jazz both lost. Keep collecting the ping...

Will state consider gay rights law?

Talk about discrimination, segregating and writing laws to protect gays is...

Gay advocates trek to LDS office

Wow, You are SO right on "Recovering". God IS waiting for US to make the...

Letters: Isn't that bribery?

I think you're thinking of a previous "president".

Meet the climbing mayor

Living room converted to a climbing gym? Well, she clearly is no slave to...

One might also call it blackmail because he knows that it would be...

Letters: Commentary ignorant

Your heartfelt letter will bring a tear to Mr. Gale's eye, your concern for...

Utah: $850M budget shortfall

If the state government was serious about cutting costs they would be cutting...

Letters: Obama 'too busy'

Did you write about your disappointment with Bushco CEO Cheney?

Re: ". . . and as long as they don't force it on others I find it appauling...

Advertisements
Advertisement