Mine-probe data withheld

Feds won't share with state panel — for now

Published: Thursday, Sept. 27, 2007 12:24 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — The U.S. Labor Department on Wednesday refused to let the Utah Mine Safety Commission have any information from the Crandall Canyon Mine accident investigation until the inquiry is over, citing "grave concerns" that the panel's involvement would jeopardize the department's work.

Commission Chairman Scott Matheson Jr. had asked the Mine Safety and Health Administration for full cooperation as the government conducts its investigation into the accident last month. The accident trapped six miners where rescuers were killed and six were injured. Matheson has said the commission is not there to investigate the accident but wants access to information.

However, in a letter sent Wednesday to Matheson, Jonathan Snare, the Labor Department's acting solicitor, asked the commission "to respect our very real need to preserve the integrity of our law enforcement investigation."

"By granting the commission members, including a member of the trade association that includes the Crandall Canyon mine owners, access to sensitive investigative information during the progress of the investigation, we run an unacceptable risk that testimony of witnesses could be prejudiced, witnesses could be intimidated and possible civil or criminal violators could be tipped off that they are under suspicion," Snare wrote. "I am sure you can appreciate the impropriety of giving the public access to such information during a law enforcement investigation."

Story continues below

Snare said the department will cooperate with the commission but "respectfully requests that you defer on your request for interviews and documents generated by the accident investigators given the obvious need for confidentially for a law enforcement investigation."

Contacted by the Deseret Morning News Wednesday, Matheson said he had not received the letter yet and wants to read it before he comments.

The Labor Department took issue specifically that the Utah Mining Association is part of the commission and it represents owners of the Crandall Canyon Mine.

"This composition of stakeholders is highly appropriate for the purposes of reviewing the roles of the federal, state and local governments and private industry in the area of mine safety and for recommending reforms, but not for creating an investigative record that must stand up to judicial scrutiny," Snare wrote.

In an interview with the Deseret Morning News, Utah Mining Association president David Litvin said he and fellow commission members would gladly sign a confidentiality agreement pledging not divulge any information pertaining to MSHA's investigation of the Crandall Canyon Mine disaster. He added the commission's purpose in requesting access to records and documents concerning the probe is to help it make better recommendations for improving mine safety in Utah.

Recent comments

What do they need info for? They know nothing about mines, They are...

retired miner | Sept. 27, 2007 at 5:39 p.m.

I'm certain that it should be mind probe, rather than mine probe. so...

Dave | Sept. 27, 2007 at 11:19 a.m.

this article was very redundant. It was a lot of different people...

GA-mom | Sept. 27, 2007 at 10:10 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

It's not like gays come to your door during dinner trying to convert you....

Scary story, I guess all LDS institutions are going to crack down more on...

How many people smile when they are having their picture taken and being...

The working remedies are good to know, because thanks to global warming,...

It's the Church's property and they can do what they want. I know if two...

Draper Days bronc riding

How come there's no coverage on the bull that jumped over the fence? I was...

DEET works great.

"The sky is falling!!" "It will never work." We're doomed." Beck's whiners...

Working Americans already pay a hefty portion of their salary for social...

Jason Sallee was booked into jail for investigation of sexual assault,...

Advertisements