From Deseret News archives:
Death of 4th seat is good
We understand the issues involved, and we are sympathetic to the cause. The District of Columbia, whose shrinking population still includes about 600,000 people, deserves full-fledged representation in the House. It's ridiculous, not to mention an embarrassment, for the residents of the capital city in the world's foremost democracy to have no say in how the nation is governed.
But it would be just as embarrassing to ignore the Constitution, the supreme law of the land, in order to grant that representation. The Senate fell three votes shy of moving the bill on for consideration Tuesday, and that was primarily for this reason.
Argue all you want about how Washington has become something the Founders did not expect a large city with hundreds of thousands of permanent residents. The fact remains that the Constitution says representatives shall be chosen by "the people of the several states." The district is not a state.
The remedy for this is to pass a constitutional amendment. Precedent for this was set when Congress and the states passed the 23rd Amendment to grant Washington three electoral votes in presidential elections.
Utah always had less to gain in this compromise than did Washington. The state was a useful pawn because it came just short of obtaining a fourth representative in the last Census and because it likely would elect a Republican to its fourth seat. The bill would have added two seats to the now 435-member House, with some question as to whether the House later would be squeezed back to its former size after the next Census.
The truth is Utah, one of the nation's fastest growing states, is almost assured of receiving a fourth seat anyway after the 2010 Census, and that seat will not be diluted by the addition of two more overall House seats.
Had this bill passed the Senate (a version already has passed the House), it would have been either vetoed by the president or bogged down by legal challenges.
Rest assured, the issue is not dead. Supporters have vowed to try again next year. But every tick of the clock makes the compromise even less relevant to Utah. A constitutional amendment may be a messy and lengthy process, but it is the only way to solve this problem.
Recent comments
Anonymous, your response is terribly hypocritical--again!How can you...
Cory Seegmiller | Dec. 17, 2007 at 3:43 p.m.
I thought about not responding to the post you made Mr. Seegmiller...
Anonymous | Sept. 21, 2007 at 4:08 p.m.
Anonymous, you're amazing! You accused those who do not agree with...
Cory Seegmiller | Sept. 21, 2007 at 10:15 a.m.
- Advocate charged with sex abuse 11:52 a.m.
- Sp. Fork city blamed for flooding 11:51 a.m.
- State to keep four-day work week 11:50 a.m.
- Bennett enlists campaign chairs 11:49 a.m.
- Miles is back, but others still out 11:48 a.m.
- Phoenix vote on temple Wednesday 11:02 a.m.
- Iran whistleblower poisoned 10:58 a.m.
- Stocks waver after jobs report 10:57 a.m.
- Robotic hand controlled by thoughts 10:51 a.m.
- Tribune Co. names new CEO 10:49 a.m.
- 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
- Witness: Mitchell wanted attention
- Unbeaten BYU takes trip to Logan
- Why is Y. ignoring spew of hatred?
- BYU says Hall incident resolved
- Max Hall: a fixture in rivalry lore
- Find joy in life, Bishop Burton says
- Utahns growing tired of Bennett
- BCS just keeps dirty laundry on spin
- Orem pair getting a rep for crime
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
909 - Cougars beat Utes in overtime
483 - Hall reprimanded by MWC
404 - Max Hall issues apology
388 - Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal
355 - Utes won't respond to Hall
276 - BYU says Hall incident resolved
241 - 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
166 - Religion in politics is tiresome
146 - BYU is champion of the state
144
I'm going to the game, no more talking, let's see what the scoreboard says...
I am a staunch Democrat but deeply regret ever voting for Obama. He is just...
I find it interesting that during the earlier days of the Utah - BYU football...
Please give me the link, I can't find a reference to sky blue on the website.
Missing the Point: You are missing the point. Max did not say BYU hates U...
Both teams have incredible home court. BYU had the longest streak in the...
As a Republican, I would want to know what is good about Mrs. Palin? She...
And so, you couldn't tolerate living where people lived "shades of gray"...
This is nothing more than a coordinated strategic move from Corporation...
don't back up comments about highway 89. DOT won't make changes until it fits...

