Congress eyes billionaires in quest for Medicare tax hike

Published: Tuesday, Sept. 11, 2007 12:19 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
James Simons, the highest-paid hedge-fund manager in the United States last year, could pay enough in Medicare taxes to provide health insurance for about 4,800 senior citizens.

Such estimates are being cited by backers of a proposal in the U.S. House of Representatives to raise taxes on hedge-fund and private-equity managers. Simons, the Renaissance Technologies Inc. chairman, earned $1.7 billion last year, according to Institutional Investor's Alpha magazine; his income is largely exempt from Medicare and other payroll taxes because it is considered a capital gain.

The House measure, sponsored by Rep. Sander Levin, a Michigan Democrat, would require those earnings to be classified as compensation and subject them to the 2.9 percent Medicare tax. He and other lawmakers are using the image of billionaires avoiding Medicare payments to win support for requiring fund managers to pay taxes at rates as high as 35 percent instead of the 15 percent capital-gains rate.

"Tax equity is really the basic issue here," said Levin. "Those who pay 15 percent don't pay Medicare when those who pay the higher tax do."

The change, which would raise as much as $1 billion annually and cover the cost of insuring about 98,000 people, would provide a small boost for Medicare, which is projected to exhaust its assets by 2019 as the U.S. population ages and health-care costs rise faster than inflation.

Story continues below

"It's a pretty small percentage," said John Holahan, a senior fellow at the Washington-based Urban Institute who studies health-care finance. "But for a program that is going to face increased financial pressure, every bit helps." The program will provide health-care coverage to more than 40 million people this year at a cost of $436 billion, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office

said in a report last month.

Simons, 69, hasn't taken a position on the tax proposal, his spokeswoman Joan Campion said. She wouldn't confirm his reported income or comment on the Medicare tax. Robert Stewart, a spokesman for the Private Equity Council, a Washington-based trade group for the largest buyout firms, said the industry opposes any tax increase and rejected Levin's assertion that the fund managers aren't paying their fair share.

Private-equity managers "pay Medicare, payroll and other taxes on their ordinary income, which can represent a significant portion of their earnings," Stewart said. "Like everyone else, they pay long-term capital-gains taxes on the profits they earn from the sale of appreciated capital assets."

Levin's bill could more than double the tax rate for some buyout-firm managers because most of their gains are long-term and currently qualify for the 15 percent capital-gains rate. Hedge-fund managers would see less difference because their short-term gains already incur a 35 percent tax. The 2.9 percent Medicare levy would be new to both groups.

Recent comments

Another problem that would be solved by the "fair tax". irf

dave | Sept. 11, 2007 at 7:01 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

This is a tragedy. I don't understand how this could've been going on for 2...

Was impressed with Gay's run today; can't wait for world championships to...

Pratty Was more than a father to me. I looked up to him so much. He made me...

Love you Millie, but you are not worth that much. If the Jazz match this...

If the Jazz want to get better and not be a so so team every year, it has to...

Fedor is right. I loved Millsap and don't blame him at all for signing the...

For those of you who are advocating that the Jazz let Milsap walk cause the...

Go get Drew Gooden who is unrestricted, and will be a better fit for a backup...

Longing for world championships to start. Gay/Bolt/Powell matchup will be the...

The contract offered to Milsap is similar to the original one the Jazz gave...

Advertisements