Immigration players learn debating skills
The council is the brainchild of Westminster College philosophy professor Jeffrey Nielsen, who believes that in a democracy ordinary citizens have the right and duty to be consulted before policy and laws are enacted.
Saturday's event followed a Citizens Council meeting last week attended by immigrants and refugees. Next week, both groups will meet together to try to reach some consensus on specific questions. That meeting, which will include both members of the anti-illegal immigration Utah Minuteman Project and undocumented workers, may prove more explosive than the past two although Nielsen has spent nine hours now teaching the groups about the process of dialogue and deliberation.
Saturday's session left Minuteman member Phil Morgan feeling unsatisfied.
"I feel like I've been conditioned," the 84-year-old Morgan complained after the meeting, which he characterized as trying to prepare him to change his mind about illegal immigration. "I'm too old for that."
Wally McCormick of the Constitution Coalition, which is made up of Minuteman members and others, was more sanguine.
"I came in very negative about (the meeting), but there are a lot of concerned people here," he said. "There's never been anything like this, where citizens are given a chance to say how we feel in an unviolent atmosphere."
Nielsen hopes one day all kinds of policy issues will have citizens councils, and each council will be made up of people chosen completely at random. For this first experiment, though, members were chosen by Nielsen and Salt Lake City Office of Diversity administrator Josie Valdez. Saturday's meeting included people with opposing views.
To deliberate and to advocate are two different things, Nielsen told the group. To advocate a position means that you "already think you have all the facts and the truth, and there's nothing you can learn from the other side." To deliberate requires the recognition that the other side may have valid points "and you can get to a better solution together" by looking for shared values.
Most of the four-hour meeting focused on abstract concepts such as "four attitudes of citizenship in a democracy," on techniques such as "sincere listening" and on stumbling blocks such as "cognitive biases." In an effort to help them expand their views, Nielsen had council members come up with a question they would like to ask people who hold an opposing view on immigration, and a question the other person might ask in return.
"Do you consider illegal aliens victims?" was Utah Minuteman Project director Eli Cawley's question for people who support approaches such as amnesty. "Why are you racist?" he thought those people might ask him.
"What would you do if your children were starving?" Rebecca Chavez-Houck would like to ask those who choose to deport undocumented workers. She knows those people would ask her, "What don't you understand about 'illegal?"'
Obviously, Nielsen acknowledged, "immigration is an overwhelming issue, and we'd have to be naive to think we can solve it." But his goal, he said, "is to create a different model for citizens to come together to practice democracy."
E-mail: jarvik@desnews.com
Recent comments
What does a "philosphy professor" know about real life? This is just...
Mary | Aug. 13, 2007 at 7:44 a.m.
When you put the two minutement comment together you get something...
James | Aug. 12, 2007 at 6:26 a.m.
- Kirk Douglas classic on DVD 11:38 a.m.
- Zion fire moving southeast 11:36 a.m.
- More school-money than expected 11:24 a.m.
- Virginia 'Freedman's' project done 11:12 a.m.
- Teen relive Mormon trek 11:12 a.m.
- Oldest American to scale Mount Everest 11:07 a.m.
- Knicks sign first-round pick 10:59 a.m.
- Armstrong third, Leipheimer fourthe 10:58 a.m.
- 6.0 quake in China 10:43 a.m.
- Big Ben celebrates 150 years 10:42 a.m.
- Jazz brass debate Millsap match
- LDS seminary principal arrested
- 2 men cited on LDS plaza
- Jazz finances not quite so bleak
- HBO defends U. logo use in 'Love'
- Reactions on Boozer speculation
- Cash for Clunkers to get rolling soon
- Utahns among Texans' investors
- Man spots his stolen car
- Jazz rookies quiet Thunder youngsters
- LDS seminary principal arrested
244 - Jazz brass debate Millsap match
157 - Bronco collecting a galaxy of recruits
141 - Jazz talking Boozer trade?
139 - Blazers may offer Millsap a contract
124 - 2 men cited on LDS plaza
114 - Stadium of Fire flag burning was fake
96 - Fairness of BCS debated
81 - Chaffetz eyes challenging Bennett
76 - Letters: Single-payer system best
75
As more and more dads are put out of work in this economy, I've been...
The photographs are mysterious, brooding, dark. They show dimples and...
Good for Milsap, but whatever he does, he's got to get rid of this Ara...
no one griped last year when millie was getting paid 700.000. jazz could have...
I have always thought we invaded Iraq out of boredom; the 50 united states...
To the 3:37 commentator, Actually the 12:07 commentator was doing a lot...
Hey Kent- First of all, the Stadium of Fire is NOT a BYU production. ...
Leave him where he is and make him work or pay to stay there.
And let's put the blame where it all belongs....on Hedo. If he hadn't...
Just when you think Utah could not possibly get any more ridiculous,...
To the 10:51 commentator, Did I say he should not be on the sex offender...
To CJ3: How many centers out there really are their teams toughest post...

