From Deseret News archives:

Star-studded 'Stardust' is dud

Published: Thursday, Aug. 9, 2007 3:02 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
STARDUST — ** 1/2 — Charlie Cox, Claire Danes, Michelle Pfeiffer; rated PG-13 (violence, vulgarity, mild profanity, brief gore)

"Stardust" is supposed to be a magical fantasy, but it's not that magical and definitely isn't fantastic.

It's merely watchable, which is surprising considering its pedigree. It's an adaptation of the well-regarded, prose-and-pictures novel by author Neil Gaiman and artist Charles Vess.

And the cast includes Michelle Pfeiffer, Robert De Niro, Peter O'Toole, Rupert Everett and Ian McKellen, who serves as narrator.

And yet, its humor is clunky; there's an off-putting amount of nastiness, and the whole thing lacks the energy and vitality that would make it memorable.

Charlie Cox ("Casanova") stars as Tristan Thorn, who has vowed to recover a fallen star. The lovelorn youth is desperately trying to impress his lady love, Victoria (Sienna Miller), and believes this may help him win her heart.

However, he's surprised when he actually finds the star, which turns out to be a young woman named Yvaine (Claire Danes). She's not thrilled to see him, though she'll need his help if she's going to return to her "home" in the sky.

Story continues below
But Tristan is not the only one looking for Yvaine. Evil sorceress Lamia (Pfeiffer) wants to cut out her heart and eat it (that will help restore Lamia's lost youth).

Would-be king Septimus (Mark Strong) is following Tristan and Yvaine, as well. He's already killed several of his brothers just to get to this point, and the rather bumbling Tristan may not put up much of a fight.

Co-screenwriter/director Matthew Vaughn ("Layer Cake") is saddled with a pair of dull leads. Cox doesn't have much charisma here, while Danes adopts an unconvincing British accent and showcases what's possibly the worst screen limp in film history (her character is supposed to be injured).

Fortunately, they and Vaughn are bailed out a little by the supporting cast. Pfeiffer has fun as the villain of the piece, and there's welcome comic relief from De Niro (as the leader of a band of sky "pirates") and Ricky Gervais (as a fast-talking trader).

"Stardust" is rated PG-13 for strong scenes of violence (sword fighting, stabbings, sorcerous attacks, animal slaughter and cruelty), suggestive language and references, scattered mild profanity, brief animal gore and use of potions and poisons. Running time: 128 minutes.


E-mail: jeff@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
David James, Paramount Pictures

Tristan (Charlie Cox), left, tries to defend his beloved Yvaine (Claire Danes) in "Stardust."

previousnext

Latest comments

BYU, Utah game highlights

I was hoping BYU would win by 3 TDs but ya know, I'm starting to like these...

Headline: "Utah adopts Saskatchewan Health Plan"! Next page headline: "Pigs...

Shame on Max. I am sure he will live to regret what he said. How ever, If BYU...

What's the news? The guy is a 20+ years old with a microscope on him. He...

S.L. wheels forward with initiative

I too applaude the efforts being made to help cyclists and motorists more...

It's about time a Cougar fought back. As another wrote, "You can only kick a...

I dare you to define the word 'classless'. But wait, I guess you already did...

Hall mouths off about hate of Utah

John 13:34-35  34"A new command I give you: Love one another. As I have...

Right on, Max! I have heard Ute fans (especially), players and former...

BYU is champion of the state

Take your response and turn it the other way. You say you have family and...

Advertisements