From Deseret News archives:
District-split law likely to stand, says Shurtleff
The opinion by the Attorney General's Office, officially requested by House Speaker Greg Curtis, R-Sandy, was made public Wednesday.
"The new law clearly raises constitutional concerns, and if a city votes to split off from an existing school district, there will likely be a legal challenge," the opinion states. "As you know, how the courts will rule depends to large extent on the standard of review they follow, and whether they will apply federal or state law. As set forth in the following legal analysis, it is the opinion of the Office of the Utah Attorney General that there is a substantial likelihood that the courts will uphold SB30."
But Riverton Mayor Bill Applegarth is not so sure.
"I think there's enough doubt here that it needs to go to court," Applegarth said.
Alta, Cottonwood Heights, Draper, Midvale and Sandy all have voted to let their residents decide whether to break away from the Jordan School District. In a separate movement in Granite district, elected leaders are poised to vote on putting the question to Holladay, South Salt Lake and Millcreek township voters in the coming weeks.
But Shurtleff says the legal issue comes down to cities' responsibilities to their residents.
"The right to vote is a pretty substantial right," he said. "If there's a voting question, the courts will often apply a higher standard. But there are voter qualification cases where courts have said no. This is different because we're not dealing with the right to vote."
The state law in question recognizes the duties of local governments to look after their residents, so they can make a decision for themselves to withdraw from a school district and not have another city intervene, Shurtleff said.
The 11-page opinion ponders the ins and outs of both state and federal case law, and laws of other states.
Comments
- NFL: Week 12 recap 12:50 a.m.
- '12 Days' bill would top $87K 12:35 a.m.
- Study finds autism therapy works 12:35 a.m.
- Boy shot following traffic stop 12:35 a.m.
- Sports on the air 12:24 a.m.
- Herbert builds his team of rivals 12:21 a.m.
- Corroon a step closer to governor 12:21 a.m.
- Monday on TV 12:18 a.m.
- Editorial: East, West and religion 12:17 a.m.
- A deficit commission? 12:17 a.m.
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
- BYU is champion of the state
- Cougars beat Utes in overtime
- Credit Coug defense for win
- Marriage definitions vary widely
- Field goals, penalties doomed Utes
- Cougar defense rose to occasion
- Banged up Jazz get best of Blazers
- Jones' joy for life remembered
- Fantasy is reality for BYU professor
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
869 - Cougars beat Utes in overtime
473 - Max Hall issues apology
145 - BYU is champion of the state
137 - Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies
117 - Cave to be sealed with body inside
116 - Rivalry Week is highly profane
90 - Hall's legacy measured today
79 - Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal
68 - Utes fall to Seattle U. at home
65
I wanted to tell them not to go. I dropped subtle hints. "My money is on...
When I was a kid, I worshipped my grandpa. He was undoubtedly my hero....
I find it interesting that many of the same people who say that we can't...
None of these teams is going to be easy. They all have fine football...
Max, no apology was necessary, but the apology was polically correct. If...
Very good piece of writing, Amy. You summarized what many of us have been...
How is a top 25 finish make Utah a top twenty team? I think what the poster...
90% of the BYU & Utah fans have class, and Hall knows it. If you don't...
This might be my favorite article I've ever read from the Deseret News. Kudos.
Thank you for not giving up and don't give up now brother and sister...
Dr. Lois Lee's work with children who are victims of child sexual...
Look at the preview for Pixar's "Up". The whole move is summarized in...



You can be the first to comment on this story.