From Deseret News archives:
Counties lose round in Grand Staircase dispute
BLM isn't place to decide road claims, federal judge says
But the ruling by U.S. District Judge Bruce S. Jenkins does not seem to justify statements by the legal advocate Earthjustice, which represented environmentalists in the case. Earthjustice said in a press release that the ruling "blocks the counties' broad seizure of wash bottoms and seldom-used jeep tracks as highways ... (and) ensured that off-road highway development could not run amok in these unique national lands."
Actually, nothing in the decision reduces the counties' right to have all their road claims decided by a court and, possibly, upheld. Jenkins did not throw out the RS2477 claims themselves but said the Bureau of Land Management was not the place to decide them.
On another crucial issue involving off-road vehicle restrictions on roads where the counties are acknowledged to have jurisdiction, the judge gave the counties leave to refile their suit under a different basis. He did not rule against their basic position that they, not the BLM, should regulate travel on the routes.
Jenkins ruled Friday against the counties' assertion that the BLM should have decided their RS2477 road claims before it formulated a travel plan for the sprawling southern Utah national monument.
Jenkins said it's not up to the BLM to decide all unresolved claims; if counties want a final decision on those matters, they can ask for a court review and shoulder the burden of proving their assertions. The burden should not be on the BLM, he wrote, citing decisions by the U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals.
Jenkins noted the BLM's plan to manage the monument mentions several times that route closures are "subject to valid existing rights."
The judge wrote, "At the core of the counties' claims is a question of sequence.
"In their view, management of road travel within the monument should be addressed by the BLM only after all of the counties' unresolved RS2477 right-of-way claims have been determined by the agency," he wrote.
Comments
- Utah Jazz Gameday glance 8:17 p.m.
- Seniors helped BYU regroup 8:00 p.m.
- TCU showdown has big implications 7:51 p.m.
- NHL: The Captain heads to the Hall 7:48 p.m.
- Jazz: Korver, Miles to be evaluated 7:43 p.m.
- Hiker rescued from narrow ledge 7:38 p.m.
- RSL unfazed by conference final 7:27 p.m.
- 12 high schools ready for 'The Turf' 7:25 p.m.
- 'Motherhood' is totally obnoxious 7:16 p.m.
- Gordon, Wallace lead Pistons 6:51 p.m.
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
216 - House passes health care bill
195 - Dirk does dirty work in Dallas
190 - Lobo suspended
173 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
149 - Speed has never been BYU's game
136 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
124 - RSL rallies to advance
103 - Thousands protest health bill
102 - Provo company innovating engines
99
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
NASA's Stardust probe continues to bring new knowledge about the nature...
It's all about getting re-elected. Of those that can vote for healthcare...
I honestly don't care if gay marriage comes to pass. What does worry me is...
GREAT SEASON South Sevier! Sat. game wasn't a true showing for your Team and...
Utah 3 TCU 45 enough said
Let the utes start crying about something........
Passing of this bill by the house will mark eventully forcing all people...
I think it interesting that if someone expresses their view point and it...
The best 2-days ever! Thank you for highlighting it!
Do you really think TCU could have beaten Tennessee, LSU, Mississippi,...
way to go Dixie and Snow Canyon! You have worked hard all season. The entire...


You can be the first to comment on this story.