From Deseret News archives:

A vote for human suffering

Published: Saturday, June 30, 2007 12:28 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The comprehensive immigration bill is now dead. And the senators who killed it have reams of principled reasons for putting a bullet through it. What's less clear is if they are willing to shoulder the responsibility for the years of hardship and suffering they have now foisted on the immigrant community.

Whatever reaction those senators were expecting from the illegal immigrant community, the reaction that came has been sorrow.

In California, the country's most popular Spanish-language talk show host — Piolin — fielded call after call from tearful mothers until he himself choked up. To a person, those mothers were worried about their children, many of whom are full citizens of the United States of America for having been born here.

Those American children have now been condemned to the shadows of society. Perhaps all those dancing on the grave of immigration reform should put some of that high-stepping energy into helping those families.

In Mexico, President Felipe Calderon was melancholy but diplomatic.

"All the United States Senate did was heighten the risk and insecurity on both sides of the border," he told the Mexican press corps.

Clarissa Martinez, the director of a major immigration reform group, told the Spanish-language television audience, "The politicians speak lovely words to us in an election year, but they lack the courage to follow up and act."

Story continues below
All that has changed is that the issue is now muddier than ever. Tim Russert of "Meet the Press" claims the senators who killed the bill will probably find that vote haunting them for years to come. And though it sounds harsh, some pundits feel that — as with Gov. George Wallace and segregation — senators such as our own Orrin G. Hatch have landed on the wrong side of history. Senators stood, for a moment, at the crossroads of a nation. Their knees buckled.

Novelist Wallace Stegner once said that the Southern states have produced so many gifted writers because the South feels a need to work through its sins against humanity.

If that's true, perhaps America's skittish senators will themselves end up winning the Nobel Prize — not for peace, but for literature.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

pathetic schedule... Why don't they schedule some decent teams? I'll be...

What a bunch of dumb comments. I miss reading my newspaper without all the...

In my letter I stated that I did not think that insurance companies were...

Disagreeing with a law does not give you the right to break the law. Telling...

Utahn aiding poor

Love and Leadership are so needed all around the world. Kudos to all who are...

Letters: Invest in business

Perhaps you should look deeper into the problem. Perhaps real business...

Utes stop Idaho State

Yes, the seventh photo does represent their season...celebrating with a...

The government is trying to take over Medicare and turn it into some...

Letters: Invest in business

To steve: Income and capital gains taxes are lower now than they have been...

Again we have another article demonizing Bush as the bad guy in Kyoto. A...

Advertisements