Displays a source of friction

Published: Saturday, April 7, 2007 12:02 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Many of the Ten Commandments displays on the grounds of courthouses, city halls and city parks in America were gifts from the Fraternal Order of Eagles in the mid-1950s. A half-century later, these and other, newer Ten Commandments monuments continue to be a source of friction.

In 2005, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on two Ten Commandments cases and came up with what appear, on the surface, to be two different conclusions. In one, the court ruled that the Ten Commandments could stay on the grounds of the Texas Capitol, because they were one of 17 monuments and therefore served "a mixed but primarily nonreligious purpose." In the other case, the court ruled that the display had to come down, because it had an "unmistakably religious" intent.

There's a difference, says BYU law professor Cole Durham, between many older Ten Commandments displays and some of the newer ones, which "are trying to garner support for their side in an ideological battle."

Since the Supreme Court rulings are all about location and context, the 2005 decisions mean that the legality of other displays will be determined on a case-by-case basis, including five Utah cases that are still pending before the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals.

Story continues below

In those cases, a Utah-based religion known as Summum sued the cities of Duchesne and Pleasant Grove after both denied Summum's request to erect a monument next to the cities' Ten Commandments displays. Summum's monument would list its Seven Aphorisms — based on the principles of psychokinesis, correspondence, vibration, opposition, rhythm, cause and effect, and gender.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

To See Ya:First your not packing the moving van! Your plagerizing Sean Penn's...

It's rotten in Baghdad

Is this some sort of new GOP talking point? It meets the criteria: A) no...

Jazz brass debate Millsap match

IN 2003 the Jazz drafted a point guard Named Mo Willaims he was a heck of a...

2 men cited in trespassing on LDS plaza

From reading the blog, posted from the gay couples own words, it is apperant...

to the 2:35 commentator, Who are you calling a pedophile? While I do...

I think it's wrong to judge someone of sinful acts, when, in actuality, none...

Is there any evidence other than text messages? Did he left his phone on his...

What planet are you from, just because someone does someting wrong doesn't...

These people were obviously trying to cause a stir. It is all part of the...

BYU football: 2010 commitments

For one, u have no room to talk smack. That JV team has beat the u in every...

Advertisements