From Deseret News archives:

Can't run state or a nation on public passion

Published: Sunday, April 1, 2007 12:31 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
While visiting Southern California last week, I made a quick trip to a grocery store. Two men approached me outside the door.

"Would you like to sign a petition to protest the high price of gasoline?" one of them asked.

It wasn't an unreasonable question. While folks in Utah have been complaining about prices rising to about $2.50 at pumps, I never found a single gas station in California that was less than $3 a gallon. Most were significantly higher.

And so my questioner's voice was tinged with passion. His body language had a populist swagger that indicated he didn't expect a lot of resistance. He certainly didn't expect the question I threw at him.

"What are you proposing?"

"We want the politicians to hear us." he said.

"And when they hear you, what will you say? Do you propose price controls? Do you support a windfall tax? Are you hoping to persuade Congress to invest more in the development of alternative fuels? Just what is it you would like me to put my name to?"

Clearly, I was beginning to get in the way of what was planned as an easy harvest of signatures. My questioner most likely was being paid for each name he gathered. The cause was of secondary importance. He turned quickly into brush-off mode.

Story continues below
"This is going all the way to Washington," he boasted. "We're sick of the high prices."

With that, I got out of his way, never bothering to tell him I'm not a California resident, anyway. But I felt like thanking him for a prime example of the dangers of popular initiatives and referenda.

Before leaving on this trip, I wrote a column about this, saying that if governments are to allow the public to write laws or overturn acts of the Legislature, they should make it difficult to do so. Some of you reacted strongly to that idea, saying you were tired of arrogant state lawmakers with the attitude that they know better than the public.

I bristle at that attitude, too. And yet the public seldom shows evidence that its collective wisdom is much better. Nor does it show much interest in being consistent. Recent opinion polls in this newspaper have shown widespread disgust with this year's Legislature over decisions to fund a soccer stadium and to start a voucher program for private schools. A separate opinion poll, however, found a widespread feeling of approval for the overall performance of the Legislature and the governor (in the governor's case, the approval was 77 percent). So much for indignation and anger.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Obama defends wars, accepts Nobel

How can all of us even imagine all the things that Pres. Obama had to face...

Letters: Let pros manage wildlife

What's the reason for going out in the woods to shoot animals? What...

Obama can't 'create' jobs

I have heard liberals say that trickle down economics doesn't work. Yet, if...

Hatch's Hanukkah tune

Way to go Bro. Hatch, you ROCK,

The fact that the liberal media has invested so much energy in trying to...

Tiger isn't a tiger anymore... he's a cheetah!

It's funny how people call Kobe just a "Good" player because (at this time)...

A nice honor for him and our country. A fitting symbol that we are regaining...

Nude bathers cited for lewdness

I normally agree with the sheriff's actions, but not in this case. At times...

Obama can't 'create' jobs

What is a professor to do when he carefully lays it out for the dunderhead...

Advertisements