Utah's 'one-party system' not beneficial

Published: Thursday, March 29, 2007 9:44 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
During the 2006 election, one local Republican candidate ran against his Democratic opponent arguing his district deserved "a representative in the Utah State Legislature who is seen as more than an interloper in a one-party system." There was a time when a "one-party system" was something to be ashamed of, but apparently not any more.

Being perceived as a "one-party" state has not exactly resulted in better treatment for Utah citizens from previous Republican-controlled Congresses or the White House. Having our votes taken for granted by the Republican Party has proven bad for both the democratic process we hold dear and for our state in general.

Perhaps the most glaring recent example was the proposed Divine Strake test. Though eventually cancelled, it took considerable outcry from the citizens of Utah. Having Republican congressmen like Chris Cannon speak favorably of the test didn't help matters.

The Republican Party demonstrated again this month why enjoying solid support in Utah won't translate easily into benefits for our state. Utah has been seeking a fourth congressional district since the 2000 Census. The Utah Legislature was even called back into special session in 2006 to redraw district boundaries in anticipation of the lame-duck Republican Congress finally taking some action on the proposal. They never did.

Story continues below

Within 48 hours of Democrats passing a bill out of committee earlier this month giving Utah the fourth congressional district it has been seeking for seven years, President Bush announced his opposition to it. No more than a couple of days passed before Sen. Bob Bennett declared the bill's chances in the Senate practically zero as a result.

Republicans serving on Utah's Capitol Hill are not immune to the arrogance that comes with almost absolute power over the legislative process. Public opinion polls have consistently shown strong support among Utahns for their neighborhood public schools. In spite of this fact, vouchers passed the House by one vote and the Senate by nine votes without a single Democrat voting in favor in either chamber.

Popular reforms that consistently enjoy two-thirds support or greater including the creation of a bipartisan redistricting committee, banning or further limiting gifts from lobbyists to legislators, and prohibiting legislators from using campaign funds for personal purposes rarely received a hearing in committee, let alone a vote on the floor of the House or Senate.

Perhaps the most significant of the reform measures introduced by Democrats during the 2007 session, but denied even the benefit of a debate in committee, was Rep. Roz McGee's legislation creating a bipartisan redistricting commission. Utah is not nearly as monolithic as it appears. Upwards of 43 percent of Utahns vote entirely or partially Democratic in just about every election. Unfortunately for Utah's voters, our Legislature has acquired national renown for using the redistricting process to select voters instead of enabling voters to hold their legislators accountable.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Guess what?!! The rest of the world thinks MORMONS ARE NOT MORAL!!!

It's rotten in Baghdad

@If I were Obama | 7:25 a.m. So funny. LMAO with this comment. Just...

"Fight the Power" is trying to make a civil rights analogy here that...

Utah Jazz finances not quite so bleak

To imply that seniority is any substitute for effort under Jerry Sloan is...

Jazz brass debate Millsap match

Both for us fans and Jazz management. Millie was a great 2nd round pick,...

Like so many laws suits, Utah will loose. This use isn't any violation of...

Let's control borders

"The Sutherland institute study shows that 96% of the immigrants lead crime...

continued: But most important, her gaffes reveal one who is woefully lacking...

suffers from a terrible case of 'god complex' wherein he thinks he is god the...

Biden or Sarah Palin? Looking at a catalogue of Biden’s gaffes, one is...

Advertisements