From Deseret News archives:
Drop the 4th seat plan
So much for all the frantic efforts last year by state politicians to come up with a bipartisan four-district map known as "Plan L."
The Democrat-controlled Congress has reasons to push the extra seat for Utah. It would come as part of a compromise that also would grant a first-ever seat to the District of Columbia. Utah's seat would almost certainly go to a Republican, and the district's seat would almost surely go to a Democrat.
But just because this effort is back before a new and differently oriented Congress doesn't mean it smells any better. In fact, the idea of an at-large seat makes it smell even worse. Should the plan become law, everyone in Utah would be represented by two House members the one from their own home district and the one representing the entire state.
And everyone in Utah and the entire nation would have something else, as well a big court battle.
By the time the law is passed and the legal case is exhausted, the 2010 Census would be so close as to render any advantage to Utah meaningless. The way this state is growing, that Census is bound to provide a fourth, and perhaps even a fifth, representative without any legal challenges.
We are sympathetic to the notion that the District of Columbia deserves representation. It makes little sense for so many U.S. citizens to lack a voice in the body that taxes them. But if those people are to be granted representation, it must come legally, and that would require an amendment to the Constitution. In 1961, the nation ratified the 23rd Amendment, which granted the district electoral votes in presidential elections. That is the proper example here.
Utah should have gotten a fourth seat after the 2000 election. It missed by a few hundred residents, and the number of full-time religious missionaries serving abroad easily would have cleared that barrier, if they had been counted.
But that's quickly becoming ancient history. Utah has little to gain any more from a legislative compromise.
Comments
- Y. student vanished in China 10:11 p.m.
- Poll: Limbaugh top conservative 10:03 p.m.
- Birthdays for Monday, Nov. 30 10:01 p.m.
- For-profit colleges get fed aid 9:58 p.m.
- Senate opens health-care debate 9:57 p.m.
- Many pilots run out of gas 9:56 p.m.
- Utah Jazz: Gameday glance 9:55 p.m.
- Iran plans large-scale N-facilities 9:52 p.m.
- 4 police officers shot dead 9:50 p.m.
- Cougs begin bowl preparations 9:40 p.m.
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
- BYU is champion of the state
- Cougars beat Utes in overtime
- Credit Coug defense for win
- Field goals, penalties doomed Utes
- Cougar defense rose to occasion
- Marriage definitions vary widely
- Banged up Jazz get best of Blazers
- Jones' joy for life remembered
- Fantasy is reality for BYU professor
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
854 - Cougars beat Utes in overtime
472 - Thunder rolls by Jazz
136 - BYU is champion of the state
136 - Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies
117 - Cave to be sealed with body inside
116 - Editorial: Poor welcome for Palin
113 - Rivalry Week is highly profane
90 - Max Hall issues apology
85 - Hall's legacy measured today
79
RIP. My heart goes to his family.
Amy, what a great article. You get it. Keep up the good work.
Paul Krueger's pick in tonight's NFL game looked a lot like his pick of Max...
Way to go Haley!!! Hope to see you playing for the U!
Of course he doesn't mean it, but kudos for trying to make up for heated...
Why don't ya all keep your comments to the game of football. I agree that...
Many (most) of us started our careers in hourly non-benefited jobs. That's...
I got tired of all the "hate" of the Ute fans at RES several years ago and...
I graduated from both the U and the Y. I choose to cheer for the U because...
I'm a huge byu fan but I am sadly disappointed in the way Hall let his anger...


You can be the first to comment on this story.