From Deseret News archives:

Female teachers punished

Utah sex-crimes cases highlight stereotypes

Published: Monday, Jan. 15, 2007 1:27 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
It seemed like a bad week for female educators in Utah — three of them appeared in court over charges of sexual misconduct with underage male students.

For prosecutors, this is a simple matter. A crime is a crime.

But for some people, the idea of a female teacher engaging in sexual activity with a boy does not strike them as criminal.

Following the sentencing this week of Melinda Lee Deluca to 90 days in jail, several bloggers on the KSL-TV comment board cracked jokes about how "lucky" this boy was and wondered where such teachers were when they were in high school.

Deluca, 30, on Wednesday was sentenced by 3rd District Judge Stephen Roth after pleading guilty to third-degree felony attempted sexual abuse in connection with sex with a 16-year-old student. Her teaching license has been revoked.

Meanwhile, in Tooele on Tuesday, 3rd District Judge Mark Kouris ordered former math remediation lab coordinator Leslie Baird, 42, to spend three months at the diagnostic unit in the Utah State Prison. She will be sentenced April 17. She previously had pleaded guilty to second-degree felony forcible sexual abuse involving two male students, both 17. She was not a certified teacher.

Story continues below
And on Friday, Kathryn Louise Parmley, 42, was scheduled for a roll-call hearing in Farmington before 2nd District Judge Rodney Page. Parmley, who formerly worked at the Davis County School District's Family Enrichment Center in Kaysville, has not been convicted of any crime. The Davis County Attorney's Office has charged her with two third-degree felony counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a 16- or 17-year-old.

She is accused of sexual activity with a 17-year-old male who was not her student. Her attorney insists she is innocent.

In the cases involving Deluca and Baird, the mothers of two victims spoke to the judges in court, and both described identical effects that the sexual relations had on their sons. Their once-happy teenagers are now deeply depressed, they no longer take part in the sports they once loved, their school work has suffered and other students shun them.

Lingering stereotypes

Gary Searle, prosecutor with the Tooele County Attorney's Office, said stereotypes linger about males and females when it comes to sex crimes.

"People just do not view males as victims in these types of cases, and it's especially true when it's a female victimizing the male," Searle said. "Some people say, 'How were you a victim in something every boy dreams about?'

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

Melinda Lee Deluca

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

We've curtailed the threat to the U.S. let the countires in that region fight...

BCS reform still needed

I fully believe that the outcome of the Texas-Nebraska game is due to the BCS...

Store planning for Palin crush

We purchased her book - read it and concluded that Sarah Palin is not the...

@radical moderate, I listen to all side of the debate. Do you? Open your...

Revive full food tax?

Anonymous | 8:43 a.m.- There is sales tax on natural gas and electricity...

Storm pounds Utah for 2nd day

thank god for global warming. Can you imagine how much snow and cold we'd...

I can't understand posts like failure 7:52. He expresses no sympathy for...

Obama has sharp criticism for GOP

Mr. President, I know that you know that your party has control of the House...

Look I had a conversation with a couple of Utah Players who played against...

U.N.: '00-'09 warmest decade

This is the biggest scam ever put on mankind. It will make liars like Al...

Advertisements