From Deseret News archives:

Estate battle can lead to family war

Published: Friday, Oct. 27, 2006 1:38 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
While hunting in 1926, a certain man ran across a mule deer with impressive antlers. He shot the deer, had the antlers mounted and hung them over his fireplace.

The man died in 1968, without a will, and the antlers were still there in 1973 when one of his sons took them. The son's siblings knew he had taken the antlers, but they didn't think much of it at the time.

Years later, those same siblings ran across a newspaper article referring to the "world class" and highly valuable antlers their brother possessed. The siblings were angry and demanded the return of the antlers.

The son wouldn't budge.

The siblings hired an attorney and sued their brother.

He still wouldn't give up the antlers.

A judge heard the case and ruled that all seven children in the family had an equal right to the antlers because their father had left no will.

The brother still wouldn't give them up and ended up serving more than 10 days in jail for contempt.

All of which goes to show that siblings will fight over anything when it comes to a parent's estate.

But Les Kotzer, an estate planning attorney in Toronto, says it doesn't have to be that way.

Story continues below
I have previously mentioned Les' book "The Family Fight: Planning to Avoid It," which was written to help parents plan their estates to avoid conflict among their children. Now he's back with a new book, "The Family War: Winning the Inheritance Battle," written with Jordan M. Atin and Barry M. Fish.

When he goes on national radio shows, Les says, he hears the same concerns over and over again. People think their mother's will does not reflect what she really wanted because she was pressured by one of her children. Or one sibling is going to attack a parent's will, and other siblings want to know how to defend it. Or a beneficiary listed in a will can't get any information from the executor and wants to know her rights.

For some of you, such questions bring back remembrance of personal experiences. But these issues should worry everyone. Les says that, as more boomers, many of whom are spenders with debt, inherit from their Depression-era parents, many of whom were savers, such battles are bound to escalate.

"The first comment (we hear) is, 'This can never happen to us. We're not rich. We rent. We're employees, not employers,"' Les says. "We walk you through how this can happen to you. For example, does one child have a joint bank account with Mom, and the others aren't on it? Or there's a painting above Mom's fireplace, and everyone loves it. Who gets it when Mom dies?"

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Someone should stick a fork in this extremist... she's done.

Newsflash. Just got an email from a member of the Salt Lake County...

To "tree-hugger | 3:15 p.m." and if we all start using less, but the...

It does no good to train a workforce for a job that doesnt exist. This is a...

I disagree with one of the opening statements."So, why is it that your cast...

You are right that this bill doesn't do enough to control costs. Countries...

Since were playing Coach here, how about Starters: PG: DWill SG: Mathews...

"Canadians I've talked to and heard of have never heard of anyone getting a...

I do believe the sun is in the south so that shadow would be to the north...

Utes remain silent about BCS

Any questions? Just one: Where did you come up with your "facts"? The...

Advertisements
Advertisement