From Deseret News archives:

Transit loses in session

Published: Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2006 11:40 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The personal income tax cut approved in Tuesday's special session was a foregone conclusion. Some $70 million was already off the table for tax-cutting purposes and could not be appropriated elsewhere. Lawmakers also created a two-track system that allows taxpayers to pick between a flat 5.35 percent tax rate with no deductions or a higher rate with many customary deductions. The accompanying rebracketing will save families about $50 starting in the 2007 filing season.

The funding of transit, however, was far from a sure thing. Instead of a slight increase to the state sales tax, which would have provided funding for a wide variety of transportation projects — light rail, commuter rail and highways, lawmakers went with a local-option model. County commissioners can place the issue on the Nov. 7 ballot. The decision provided Salt Lake County with an alternative to raising property taxes an estimated $900 million for light-rail expansion.

A sales tax is preferable to such a large hike in property taxes, so give lawmakers their due on that front. But why not bite the bullet and seek the tax increase statewide, so that much needed transportation projects such as commuter rail, highway improvements and TRAX extensions could be expedited?

Story continues below
Perhaps lawmakers didn't want to be saddled with enabling voters to increase the state sales tax while lawmakers were approving a cut in personal income taxes. The Utah Taxpayers Association estimates the sales tax increase and the income tax hike will be a wash for taxpayers in counties that approve the sales tax. Admittedly, it's a little wishy-washy to, on the one hand, lower the sales tax rate on food statewide only to create a mechanism to increase sale taxes for transit.

Lawmakers rationalized that since 40 percent of Utahns live in Salt Lake County, local officials should decide for themselves what local projects should have priority.

That makes sense on some levels, but there is also something to be said for moving up the time line on transportation projects statewide. Commuter rail isn't as much of a priority in Salt Lake County as TRAX extensions. It's more critical to residents of Utah, Davis and Weber counties. They need to step up and commit the funds for this much-needed transportation option.

Salt Lake County residents must likewise make an investment in their transportation future because lawmakers, in an election year, prefer to cut taxes rather than authorize tax hikes.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I thank Gov. Mike Leavitt for his innovative mind set for the state 10+ years...

Dr. Hudson was a new professor when I was at BYU in the IR program 20 years...

Letters: Hatred goes 2 ways

We're cougar fans and went to the BYU/UTAH game. We sit over by the visiting...

Utahn's pet python dies at age 43

An amazing longevity record! I'm sorry for the loss of such a beautiful...

So now choosing to keep your family together in the face of adultery is...

When was the last time won an NCAA tourney game and when was the last time...

Miller predicted Tiger's rough road

I think you have taken this way too far. What people do on their own time...

Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal

Get over it people! Max Hall said some stupid things in the heat of the...

it looks like I'm stuck in Canada where I actually was able to find a job...

I can't even believe the uneducated, misinformed and wacky comments on this...

Advertisements