From Deseret News archives:

Lee ignores truth in distorted film about Katrina

Published: Sunday, Aug. 27, 2006 5:52 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Spike Lee took his cameras and crew to New Orleans to film a documentary about Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath. The four-hour production, which aired on HBO, is, unfortunately, about as destructive as was the disaster it depicts.

At a time when we need light and understanding, Lee has delivered darkness, anger and hatred. Those who will be hurt the most by the distorted and untruthful picture that Lee has concocted are the poor blacks he purports to want to help.

It's clear that Lee did not go to Louisiana in search of truth. He went to Louisiana to carefully construct a documentary that would support the conclusion he had already reached. That conclusion: Poor blacks suffered and died as a result of the indifference of a detached and racist Bush administration in general and President Bush in particular.

The film commits egregious journalistic sins of commission and omission, carefully selecting and editing footage to indict Bush, including only commentators who support the conclusions that Lee had already reached, and selectively omitting reams of information relevant to the complex truth of what actually happened.

Story continues below
Since Lee already knew the truth, he didn't have much need to examine material such as "A Failure of Initiative," Congress' investigation into Katrina, which shows failure and breakdown at all levels of government — local, state and federal. It also was of little interest to Lee that primary responsibility for disaster preparation and management is at the level of local and state government, not federal.

But New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin comes off in the production as just one cool dude. He shows up at regular intervals over the four-hour production, talking New Orleans jive and being one straightforward sincere guy who was trying to do his job.

No mention is made of the hurricane simulations and emergency evacuation plans that he totally ignored. No reference is made to the famous picture of the parking lot filled with flooded school buses that Nagin chose not to use to evacuate residents in poor areas.

Central to the Katrina story is the failure of the levees. Indeed, Lee's film is called "When the Levees Broke."

But who is responsible for ignoring the warnings over the years that the levees protecting New Orleans were inadequate? Bush? Of course not.

It was Louisiana's congressional delegation that was responsible to ensure that their constituents' interests were being represented and that funds were being appropriated to fix sub-standard levees. But not a single Louisiana senator or congressman is ever mentioned or appears in "When the Levees Broke."

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

How ridiculous. It's not even a trashy nose ring, she has it because it's a...

Utahns swap clunkers for trucks

Traded in my daughters gas guzzling clunker for a compact car. Best...

I hope this is well-attended. Too many times, we (esp. LDS) and put on the...

The Showdown in Cowtown. TCU will be looking for revenge. Utah will be...

Way to go girls. Yes they all played great, it would be hard to pick the...

Congrats on the first win! finish out last place please so we get the #1...

Y. scientists rip lawmakers on climate

Re: Kevin in the Terrace | 10:46am You want me to "...Try the peer...

Utes pound winless Lobos

is everyone forgetting Utah beat New Mexico.....New Mexico has not won a...

Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings

My mistake. My memory failed. In 1995 the Jazz did finish 60-22 and 27-14...

2A: Broncos stampede South Sevier

between south summit and san juan have been great like in 98 south summit was...

Advertisements
Advertisement