'Atomic veterans' sift fallout from court ruling

Published: Monday, Aug. 28, 2006 12:25 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — Radiation exposure took Alice Broudy's husband a generation ago.

This week, a court ruling sliced away at her bid for redress.

In a quiet ruling that nonetheless resonates nationwide, a federal appellate court rejected efforts by Broudy and others seeking claims on behalf of "atomic veterans," exposed to radiation during nuclear tests and in post-war Japan. The same court simultaneously rejected bids by other veterans exposed to biological and chemical agents.

Taken together, the dual rulings by the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals will likely impede many veterans hoping for compensation. At the very least, it will complicate future claims.

"It's a significant ruling," Washington-based attorney David Cynamon, who represented veterans in both cases, said Friday. "Unfortunately, it's a significantly bad ruling."

A Department of Veterans Affairs spokesman couldn't be reached to comment.

Broudy, a resident of California's Orange County, has long been seeking full compensation for the death of her husband, a Marine major who was repeatedly exposed to radiation. She has company.

George Woodward, who lives north of Wichita, Kan., in the town of Miltonvale, was exposed to radiation during a 1955 test blast. Kathy Jacobovitch, a resident of Vashon Island, Wash., lost her father through exposure to contaminated ships in Puget Sound. Ernest Kirchmann, a 62-year-old Navy veteran who lives south of Minneapolis in tiny West Concord, who's filed a separate lawsuit, was exposed during a 1964 nuclear submarine accident.

Story continues below

"It isn't just my personal case," Broudy said Friday. "It's the entire veterans community. It makes me so angry."

Broudy married her husband, Charles, in 1948. Three years earlier, he'd walked the war-poisoned streets of Nagasaki. Within a decade, he was facing radiation in the Nevada desert. He died of lymphatic cancer in 1977. Though she has since received partial compensation, Broudy has been confronting the federal government for more. She has now lost three separate lawsuits.

"This closes the door," Cynamon said of the latest appellate court ruling, which was issued Wednesday. "It will make it very difficult, if not impossible, for individuals who are victimized by government cover-ups."

All told, an estimated 220,000 U.S. soldiers were allegedly exposed to radiation in the 1940s and 1950s. Some, such as William Yurdyga of Sacramento, Calif., claimed in an earlier lawsuit that they were exposed following the Hiroshima or Nagasaki atomic blast. Others claimed exposure during Cold War testing.

The three-member appellate panel wasn't ruling on whether the atomic veterans deserve compensation. A 1988 law provides that. To succeed, though, veterans must prove they were present at a radioactive site and that they contracted a radiation-related illness or were exposed to a cancer-causing radiation level.

Recent comments

I was a member of Joint Task Force 8 during the Christmas Island...

Paul D. Cannon | April 28, 2009 at 12:08 p.m.

My husband took part in operation teapot in May 1955. He died of...

J. Schonmaker | Nov. 13, 2008 at 1:39 p.m.

I took part in operation tea pot in 1955 in feb and in june and in...

joseph s cohen | April 23, 2008 at 6:15 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

that didnt stop them with the guy they acused in elizebeth smart case but he...

It is a root beer ice cream recipe, not a root beer recipe. Do a search on...

Teachers struggle with district cuts

Hello! I'm 19 years old and I was thinking of becoming a teacher. After...

Time for a revolution

LOL! (this is comedy, right?)

Palin mistreated

re: Honestly .... | 10:18 a.m. "The GOP has nothing if they don't have an...

Plaisted was drafted by the Seattle Sonics (now Oklahoma City Thunder) then...

Obama not a magician

I'm writing from Amsterdam, where I'm attending a conference. The...

Obama not a magician

I think the Right better start listening to fellow GOP leader, Colin Powell....

Please tell me why I should care what Genevieve Atwood thinks. Please also...

Palin mistreated

It's the nature of the game. Big-time politics is a messy affair, and many...

Advertisements