From Deseret News archives:

Utah's insanity laws tough

State has cut wording on knowing an act is wrong

Published: Wednesday, July 26, 2006 10:57 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
PROVO — A man who says God told him to gun down a dozen people can't hope to be found "not guilty by reason of insanity" if tried in Utah.

Neither could a Texas mother who drowned her children in a bathtub under the deluded belief that she was saving their souls from Satan.

But that verdict is an option in Texas. And on Wednesday, Andrea Yates was found not guilty by reason of insanity in her second murder trial for drowning her five children in 2001.

However, Utah is one of three U.S. states that have abolished the wording in the traditional insanity plea so those accused of murder can't claim they didn't know their actions were wrong.

"It's not a defense in Utah that you think you've been commanded by God to kill somebody," said Creighton Horton, chief of the Utah attorney general's criminal justice division. "You still know you're killing a human being."

Utah's mental-defense laws became tougher almost two decades ago when lawmakers removed the phrase "appreciating the wrongfulness of the act" from the law. The change makes it more difficult for attorneys to defend mentally ill clients.

Tom Means, head of the Utah County Public Defender Association, says it's "an uncommon defense.

Story continues below
"It's so rigorous," he said. "It's a very difficult defense to prove."

Means, though, is trying to do it. He's using the rare defense in the case of a man charged with first-degree murder for fatally shooting his brother in June 2005.

Eryk Drej told police he killed his brother to prevent him from killing another woman and selling her organs on the black market. In another bizarre act, Drej told officials he had placed "smiley faces" around his mother's American Fork home to warn his brother of impending danger.

After two competency reviews Drej was found competent to understand the legal proceedings. Now, however, mental health experts will be evaluating the 32-year-old man for his mental state at the time of the shooting.

Insanity laws in Utah

Utah and many other states tightened their insanity laws shortly after the attempted assassination of President Ronald Reagan in 1981. After a trial in 1983, shooter John Hinckley Jr. was found "not guilty by reason of insanity."

Defense attorneys cited an obsession with the movie "Taxi Driver" and its star Jodie Foster as the driving forces behind Hinckley's acts.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I find it interesting that many of the same people who say that we can't...

Cougs begin bowl preparations

None of these teams is going to be easy. They all have fine football...

Max Hall issues apology

Max, no apology was necessary, but the apology was polically correct. If...

Very good piece of writing, Amy. You summarized what many of us have been...

U. eyes bowl for redemption

How is a top 25 finish make Utah a top twenty team? I think what the poster...

Max Hall issues apology

90% of the BYU & Utah fans have class, and Hall knows it. If you don't...

This might be my favorite article I've ever read from the Deseret News. Kudos.

Y. student vanished in China

Thank you for not giving up and don't give up now brother and sister...

Child prostitutes don't get help

Dr. Lois Lee's work with children who are victims of child sexual...

Look at the preview for Pixar's "Up". The whole move is summarized in...

Advertisements