From Deseret News archives:

Shaken to pieces

Unreinforced masonry buildings take biggest hit from the 'big one'

Published: Tuesday, April 25, 2006 12:38 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Damage also was not bad in Jordan School District in southern Salt Lake County. It assessed all its schools in 1990 to predict how they would do in an earthquake, according to Herb Jensen, the district facilities manager. It then began a program to replace or retrofit schools, usually when other remodeling projects were also done.

By 2006, work was completed at all but six of Jordan district's 100 buildings. Even at the ones that still lacked upgrades, Jensen said they were generally designed "to hold together long enough to allow evacuation after an earthquake."

The large Granite School District in the central portion of Salt Lake County did not do as much to prepare.

Of its 89 schools, about 35 had received "some earthquake enhancements over the years during a major remodeling, such as when a new roof was installed, to help tie the roof to the walls" to help survive ground shaking, Randy Ripplinger, spokesman for the district, said in 2006. A state study in 2006 said only 15 schools were considered up to current seismic code.

With so few schools considered truly safe seismically, a state study in 2006 said Granite would have needed $253 million to seismically upgrade its schools then.

With such problems, sixth-grade students at Granite's Hillsdale Elementary in West Valley City proceeded to make a surprising discovery in 2005 as they did exercises with Geographic Information Systems software and maps.

Story continues below
They found that their school sits on top of a fault.

It is part of the Granger fault. Geologists had predicted correctly in 2006 that a big quake on the Wasatch fault would make the smaller Granger fault also shake "in sympathy," and that it would leave a 3-foot scarp, or ledge, along much of its length. Sitting on that fault did not exactly help Hillsdale when the 2008 quake hit.

According to a state survey in 2006 among selected school districts, Alpine School District in Utah County had about two-thirds of its schools meet or "somewhat meet" seismic safety codes then.

Provo School District in 2006 sought a $35 million bond to improve and build some new schools, which voters debated and would eventually pass (but much of the construction did not come before the 2008 quake). Also, Davis School District (where 37 schools needed attention to seismic code) held a $230 million bond election in June 2006, which voters approved.

A group called SAFE — Save All From Earthquakes — had tried lobbying legislators back in 2006 to spend more to seismically upgrade schools but said it found little support.

In a letter to legislators then, SAFE said, "We could lose a generation of children if we stay in denial about the seismic vulnerability of Utah school buildings." It added, "We do not know how long we have, so we need to act now before it is too late."

Recent comments

On the specific date mentioned in the article, it isn't an extremely...

Ixy | Feb. 23, 2008 at 3:32 a.m.

What percentage is it that this would really happen?

Ray | Jan. 10, 2008 at 5:06 p.m.

Image

Dave Marshall is dwarfed by the rotunda tier girder system beneath the Capitol that will help it withstand the shaking of an earthquake.

previousnext

Latest comments

There isn't a SINGLE principle of the gospel that's based in fear OR...

Kurt Bestor: Joy for the world

Get David Archuleta's new CD, Christmas From The Heart. Some of the...

USU home-court streak ends

usu lined the byu game up for 2 years...stew and the team lost focus after...

Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing

He does use videos, but he uses clips that are taken out of context. Or he...

And if you can't report the news, report the truthiness the utah armchair...

USU home-court streak ends

is classless. We lost to St Mary's granted they are not a traditional power...

it sounds like you and I want a lot of the same things. Except I see obama as...

delherren: I know exactly what you mean. It really bothers me that so many...

Letters: Liberal because LDS

You have conviently given all the woes of society to liberals. That's a...

Gems losing out in box office

Heck, I still watch and enjoy Polanski's films (even as I condemn his crime...

Advertisements