From Deseret News archives:

Shaken to pieces

Unreinforced masonry buildings take biggest hit from the 'big one'

Published: Tuesday, April 25, 2006 12:38 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Editor's note: New estimates for what a 7.0 earthquake could do to the Wasatch Front are scary: It could kill more than 6,000 people, injure 90,000 and cause a $40 billion economic hit. In a five-part series, the Deseret Morning News describes such a future quake — as if worst-case scenarios proved to be true.

Over the decades, Wasatch Front residents built, sold and resold tens of thousands of pretty brick homes. Unfortunately, such houses — at least those that lacked seismic upgrades — turned out to be death traps in Utah's great 7.0 earthquake of 2008.

It was not just homes. It was all masonry buildings without reinforcing steel. Too many of the brittle structures could not flex well with strong ground shaking on the wintry afternoon of Feb. 1, so many buildings snapped like chalk and fully or partially collapsed. That included many schools, where casualty numbers were staggering; churches; government buildings and businesses — but mostly houses.

Some such buildings — as well as many of other construction types — dodged damage because of recent seismic upgrades to them, including such landmarks as the state Capitol, Salt Lake City-County Building and the Tabernacle.

Story continues below
Also, for example, a few school districts that had spent hundreds of millions of dollars on seismic upgrades fared well, but those that did not saw scores of schools severely damaged. Sadly, as had been predicted back in 2006, more than 700 students and teachers were killed in schools, and another 13,000 were injured.

Many hospitals paid for being too near faults and landslide areas.

Recent rebuilding of many bridges allowed them to survive, but a high number of older ones — built mainly in the 1960s and '70s as interstate freeways were constructed — were damaged or failed.

But the worst news of all for structures still came from those "unreinforced masonry" buildings.

Unreinforced masonry

Warnings had been given about unreinforced masonry buildings for years. Steve Bartlett, a University of Utah assistant professor of civil and environmental design, said during a 2006 community meeting on quakes that they are "the single largest threat to loss of human life" in an earthquake.

He was right, and their failures contributed greatly to the 6,200 deaths and 90,000 injuries in the 2008 quake — numbers close to those predicted in 2006 by Bob Carey, earthquake specialist for the state Office of Emergency Services, using computer modeling.

Recent comments

On the specific date mentioned in the article, it isn't an extremely...

Ixy | Feb. 23, 2008 at 3:32 a.m.

What percentage is it that this would really happen?

Ray | Jan. 10, 2008 at 5:06 p.m.

Image

Dave Marshall is dwarfed by the rotunda tier girder system beneath the Capitol that will help it withstand the shaking of an earthquake.

previousnext

Latest comments

BYU prof a 'Top Global Thinker'

congratulations on bringing up a very tender subject.I often wondered what...

Prep swim rankings

I love the T Birds. You're going all the way this year. Simply the best....

I'm with you. Neither party truly serves the people or is looking out for...

Why is Y. ignoring spew of hatred?

Do some of you people know how dumb you sound? We have the self-righteous...

Expert paid $500K for Mitchell report

There are attorneys in Salt Lake City who bill $500 per hour. Those who feel...

less than a penny for a .22 bullet

Aggies shoot past Cougars

Until BYU wins a NCAA tourney game they have no room to talk trash in...

Utah court rules against coal plant

Too bad that at my home here in Richfield, unemployment is sky high, and we...

You know they might prosecute the hackers or the leakers, but the information...

Letters: Not all Muslims the same

You are an ignorant bigot. Using that kind of logic, there are 12 million...

Advertisements