From Deseret News archives:

Chief economist's departure is troubling

Published: Thursday, April 6, 2006 7:12 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
With the quick retirement last week of longtime Utah Tax Commission chief economist Doug Macdonald, a lingering question in state politics once again surfaces.

What is the balance between objective, differing opinions and the monolithic executive and legislative branches of state government, where especially in Republican-dominated Utah differing points of view are often not accepted, sometimes not even tolerated?

First a disclaimer: I've known Macdonald for 25 years. I've found him to be honest, straightforward and professional in his economic/tax work.

As the head of a small, but talented, three-person economic unit for the Tax Commission, Macdonald's tax collection/economic prediction models have, over time, been some of the most accurate in all state governments.

The tax reports, combined with a fiscal conservative policy by the GOP-run Legislature and a string of Republican governors, have resulted in Utah consistently being named by various groups as one of the best-run states in the nation.

It was Macdonald's professional discussions about GOP Gov. Jon Huntsman's "fairer/flatter" rate income tax proposal, which will go before a May special legislative session, that prematurely ended Macdonald's long career.

Story continues below
You see, Macdonald was telling some people in private, and even sometimes in public, that all was not perfect with Huntsman's reform. Some individuals and groups, like retired senior citizens, could see their taxes go up (if only slightly) under the Huntsman plan — or at the very least, the wealthiest among us would get more of a benefit under "reform" than would middle-income Utahns.

Some GOP legislators have been battling Macdonald, et al., in the Tax Commission for some time. Longtime advocates of tax changes in Utah, like the Utah Taxpayer Association, have also had run-ins with Macdonald and his economic unit before — public battles over tax policy as well as private fights over how much of a fiscal note to place on tax-cutting legislation.

Now, in talking with Macdonald, he clearly says that such fights, while tiresome and perhaps even troubling in a public policy type of way, were a part of his taking early retirement at age 58. It must be said that like thousands of other veteran state workers Macdonald decided to leave early to get a very generous post-retirement state health insurance program.

Last Friday was the deadline to retire and get extra health insurance before a 2005 legislative cutback in workers' benefits kicked in.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Hall reprimanded by MWC

So what you're saying is Max was misquoted? Because he sure made it crystal...

Editorial: East, West and religion

I always get such a kick out of these “enslave the minds of men”...

Liberals complain about the mixing of religion with non-liberal politics, yet...

Don't think "Logan Canal - this pipeline isn't a dirt ditch or canal. It's an...

Letters: Hall is an embarrassment

12:14 p.m. My understanding is that Beer is already prohibited in RES and...

College Football Final's take was 'the reason I have a problem with his...

Rivalry Week is highly profane

Well, I am gad that the comments are moderated, I just think at times...

Hall reprimanded by MWC

Wah, Wah, Wah. So the truth hurts get over it. Max you are awesome and BYU...

Ute fans. Four Words. He Told The Truth.

Hall reprimanded by MWC

That's the difference. Utah players talk on the field, and say nothing off...

Advertisements