Evolution bill may lose its 'origins of life' wording

Lawmaker wants to delete all references to 'origins of life'

Published: Thursday, Feb. 23, 2006 12:13 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
A controversial bill challenging the way evolution is taught in Utah public schools is evolving again.

SB96's House sponsor, Rep. Jim Ferrin, R-Orem, wants to substitute the bill a third time, taking out all references to the "origins of life" but still aiming to keep teachers from telling students they evolved from apes.

But that can happen only if the House Rules Committee agrees to put the bill up for its final legislative debate.

The changes didn't win over school officials who oppose the bill, primarily because it treads on the state school board's authority to set curriculum.

But a new poll shows Utahns support the Legislature's move to regulate evolution lessons.

Fifty-five percent of Utah residents surveyed by Dan Jones & Associates somewhat or strongly favor legislation requiring public school teachers to "teach that evolution is not indisputably proven and there could be other reasons for human development."

Forty percent said they strongly or somewhat oppose such a measure, and 5 percent didn't know.

The poll of 415 Utah adults, conducted for the Deseret Morning News and KSL-TV Feb. 14-16, has a plus or minus 5 percent error margin.

Story continues below

Evolution is central to the high school biology core curriculum.

Sen. Chris Buttars, R-West Jordan, last summer said he received parent complaints that children were being taught they evolved from apes, bringing into question their faith on creation. His SB96 has attempted to stop that from happening.

The bill's Senate debates centered on the merits of Charles Darwin's theory of evolution and were chock-full of religious references.

Opponents have feared the bill would open the door to teaching creationism or "intelligent design" — the idea that life is too complicated to be explained in public school by Darwin's theory alone, which a Pennsylvania federal court earlier this winter struck down as unconstitutional.

Ferrin attempted to take religion out of the discussion when the bill came to the House. His proposed substitute would erase references to the origins of life and tighten language to zero in on evolution.

"We do not presently teach origins of life in our curriculum, and I didn't want to inadvertently have a requirement (the State Board of Education) create curriculum to address that," Ferrin said.

So, students could be told there is some evidence that leads to the inference that apes and humans share a common ancestor. But that could not be taught as an indisputable fact.

"We can infer all we want to about the origin of the species . . . but let's not (characterize) those inferences as a proven fact. Let's not mislead our kids," Ferrin said. "It's not my desire schools be teaching any notions about religion. But it's also not my desire for us to be teaching as fact that which has not been proven as fact."

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Deseret Morning News graphic

previousnext

Latest comments

Kruger plays, Maynor stays in D-league.

Science is not settled

This much I do know, at the time of the dinasaurs, it was hotter than now, at...

Chaffetz joins war on drugs

The war on drugs has not brought any improvements in drug abuse. Time to...

Obama controls all

"We DID rise up. At the voting booth. We rid ourselves of the 8 year cancer...

Does anyone remember how good we are with a healthy Boozer? O.K. so he said...

Tell it to the 11,000 residents of Tuvalu, all of whom had to resettled in...

It's amazing to me how much people want to create controversy, when in...

Happy Birthday, Realist! You are now 115 years old. Or, did you just type...

yay, by the time we sign everyone next year we will be about 20 million over...

This angelic little girl's story has and will continue to haunt all of Salt...

Advertisements