From Deseret News archives:

Senate committee passes bill that clarifies the use of peyote

Published: Tuesday, Feb. 7, 2006 9:41 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
A man who escaped state prosecution but now faces federal drug charges spoke out Monday against legislation that would reconcile federal and state law over the legal use of peyote.

The bill, SB60, passed the Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice Committee.

"This bill is not about religious freedom," said sponsoring Rep. Curtis Oda, R-Clearfield. "It's about guaranteeing the agreements that were made in the 1994 congressional act."

HB60 would provide a clear definition of who can and cannot use peyote. Under federal law, only members of a federally recognized Indian tribe can use peyote for the purpose of religious ceremonies.

State law isn't so clear, however. In fact, bill supporters cited a 2004 Utah Supreme Court decision that said James "Flaming Eagle" Mooney had a right to distribute peyote to non-American-Indian members of his Native American church.

Mooney, who faces federal charges over his possession of the drug, told lawmakers that not allowing white members of the church to use peyote was discrimination.

"It's a racial statement with racist bylaws," he said.

Story continues below
Indeed, some senators had constitutional concerns with the bill. Although federal law was based on prior treaties, without access to those treaties, some senators wondered whether they would be violating religious freedom and the 14th Amendment.

Looking at it from a religious point of view, "I do see a major equal protection issue," said Republican Sen. David Thomas of South Weber. But from a point of view that includes the treaties, "I understand how we can do this."

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Same old story for Jazz

Glad I watched the RSL match.

Letters: Sodom and Gomorrah

Marvin, my head is spinning from your double speak. You say you have...

I think "restore" is the appropriate word here. The sales tax used to apply...

TCU creams U.

No, not the Utes performance against TCU or BYU's against NM. What is truly...

Win in New Mexico good for Y?

BYU has a history of letting good games and press get to their heads. They...

Bennett is a good, decent man who should NOT be re-elected because many like...

A summit is just another way of saying the President isn't going to do what...

"Price-elasticity of demand" Wow. Is this also known as "My child is in pain...

Costly mistakes doomed Utes

Eating Crow and Humble Pie all in the same meal! Hahahaha! Looks like Utah...

TCU creams U.

Wow! Glad I watched the RSL game.

Advertisements
Advertisement