From Deseret News archives:
Only legislature can purge laws, court says
In a ruling issued Thursday evening, the Denver-based appellate court found that a Salt Lake County man, who was charged with a misdemeanor after burning a smiley face onto a U.S. flag, lacked standing to bring his case before the court because Salt Lake County District Attorney David Yocom's office ultimately dismissed the charge.
But in their decision, Judges Michael McConnell, Monroe McKay and Timothy Tymkovich gave a nod to the Utah Legislature's ability to remove laws that have been deemed unconstitutional by the nation's highest court.
"There is no procedure in American law for courts or other agencies of government other than the legislature itself to purge from the statute books laws that conflict with the Constitution as interpreted by the courts," the opinion states.
The judges, however, did note that the weight of precedent by U.S. Supreme Court rulings generally protects citizens from being prosecuted under unconstitutional laws.
In October 2002, frustrated with the justice system and "bored," Kris Winsness burned the image of a "smiley face" onto a U.S. flag and hung it on his garage door.
County prosecutors dismissed the charge against Winsness without prejudice, allowing them to refile the charge at any time. However, in an affidavit, Yocom assured that his office would not prosecute anyone under the statute.
During oral arguments held at the University of Utah last August, Salt Lake attorney Brian Barnard argued that Winsness was still at risk of being charged under the statute again, even after Yocom leaves office as DA.
In their ruling Thursday, the judges concluded that such a threat was not a realistic one, pointing out that there is a "deterrent effect of damages actions against executive officials who violate clearly established constitutional rights."
To also deem Utah's statute unconstitutional would simply be "redundant" in light of the U.S. Supreme Court's 1989 ruling in Texas vs. Johnson, which struck down Texas' flag desecration law, they said.
The judges also noted that Winsness had a right to sue for monetary damages, but that Winsness did not ask for money, but rather to repeal the law.
A second plaintiff, Ken Larsen, claimed he feared prosecution for writing on replicas of the Utah state flag while briefly running as a candidate for governor. The judges ruled Larsen had even less standing that Winsness because Larsen had never been charged, only feared being charged.
The ruling upholds a lower federal court ruling that dismissed the suit.
E-mail: gfattah@desnews.com
Comments
- Plan would open HOV lanes 12:03 p.m.
- Navajo politics turn sour 11:59 a.m.
- Focus: Put Christmas back in stores 11:53 a.m.
- Openly gay Episcopal leads vote 11:47 a.m.
- Blog: The unnatural outcast 11:40 a.m.
- More folks want gift cards 11:34 a.m.
- Russian nightclub fire kills 106 11:28 a.m.
- 5 peacekeepers killed in Darfur 11:23 a.m.
- Fusing furniture with different styles 11:09 a.m.
- Garden gold in piles of leaves 11:03 a.m.
- Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony
- Mr. Football 2009: Tuni Kanuch
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
- 5A high school football All-State
- George lost in rivalry hatefest
- 4A high school football: All-State
- Utah Jazz going green with unis
- MVPs wrap up stellar prep careers
- Jazz outrun Pacers
- Nutty Putty Cave to be sealed today
- Hall reprimanded by MWC
410 - Why is Y. ignoring spew of hatred?
300 - BYU says Hall incident resolved
247 - Letters: Liberal because LDS
240 - 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
189 - Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry
185 - Aggies shoot past Cougars
179 - Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
122 - N.Y. Senate rejects gay marriage
119 - Max Hall: a fixture in rivalry lore
118
Trolley Square's annual Holiday Open House will feature visits with...
That does it — I'm having an affair! Thanks to Tiger Woods, David...
First, a big thank you to all who posted questions here for me to ask...
I feel few of us thinks Koufos stinks. However, how on earth is he going to...
Jesus said: I come not to bring peace, but the sword . . .
The BYU professors would probably consider Jesus "anti-intellectual" because...
havent played anybody with bigs playing def. but we all new boz would be...
We should make sure that we aren't penalizing those students who take math at...
Enterprise beats PV by 20 Then they beat Hurricane VARSITY not JV. And just...
Harpring was one of the most entertaining players to watch over the past 5...
It's about time that each team was supported!!!! We can be fans of our team,...
were anything like Mad Max and BYU fans it's no wonder they could not settle...
If one thinks that most LDS aren't conservative, they should check Utah's...



You can be the first to comment on this story.