From Deseret News archives:
Case could have nationwide impact
Federal court looks at 'super majority' rule for wildlife initiatives
The answer by a federal appellate court could have nationwide implications.
An attorney representing a coalition of animal rights groups, including the Humane Society of the United States, the High Uintas Preservation Council and the Initiative and Referendum Institute, argued before the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday that the "super majority" requirement violated First Amendment free speech rights by stifling attempts to push initiatives limiting the hunting of wildlife in Utah.
However, an assistant Utah attorney general countered that the Utah Constitution still allows wildlife proponents to pursue a ballot initiative.
"The First Amendment does not protect success" in winning over Utah voters, he said.
In a rare move, the case was heard before an almost complete panel of all 12 circuit judges at their request. Typically appeals hearings are head by a panel of only three judges.
In the hearing, Baskin said the 1998 amendment singled out a particular cause to prevent wildlife initiatives from passing in Utah. At the time, members of the Utah Legislature and hunting rights groups were concerned over a movement by animal rights groups to push for initiatives limiting wild game hunting in other states and were concerned such initiatives might spring up in Utah.
Proponents, who have admitted to pushing such initiatives in other states, now say they have decided not to invest money in initiatives in Utah due to the poor chances of winning a two-third majority.
"They are stopped dead in their tracks," Baskin said.
Some appellate judges pointed out that the amendment still does not prevent initiative proponents from debating and arguing their case with Utah residents.
One judge asked if Utah required all initiatives to pass with a two-third vote, would that be a problem. Baskin said no because the law would apply evenly to all types of initiatives.
Some judges took issue with the fact that none of Baskin's groups had tried to bring an initiative to Utah, nor have solid plans in the future.
Comments
- Two American pilots die in Iraq 12:47 a.m.
- Murder suspect is vetran, avid skier 12:47 a.m.
- MLB: Zambrano's mom kidnapped 12:32 a.m.
- Lambert surprisingly tops news 12:25 a.m.
- Philadelphia transit strike ends 12:25 a.m.
- TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd 12:24 a.m.
- 12 high schools ready for 'The Turf' 12:17 a.m.
- RSL unfazed by conference final 12:17 a.m.
- Korver and Miles to be evaluated 12:17 a.m.
- Today on TV 12:13 a.m.
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
216 - House passes health care bill
201 - Lobo suspended
173 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
151 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
129 - RSL rallies to advance
103 - Thousands protest health bill
102 - Provo company innovating engines
101 - Utes pound winless Lobos
89 - BYU cuts Women's Research Institute
88
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
NASA's Stardust probe continues to bring new knowledge about the nature...
STOP blaming the Democrats, BLAME THE REPUBLICANS FOR 8 YEARS DOING NOTHING...
The best way to break the law is to become someone who enforces the law.
It's a real shame so many folks have never gotten out and gotten to know the...
It's all talk... you do not have any evidence for your claims. You assume...
Maybe if you could bat .408 in the major leagues, you too would be paid a...
I prefer the “Wizard of Earthsea” quartet by Ursula Le Guin, an...
The bottom line question that no one can possibly answer is; what will be the...
It looks to me like special treatment.
Jazz will have a tough week, with what should be a easy win against the...
I am very excited for this game. As much as I want the Utes to win, it won't...


You can be the first to comment on this story.