From Deseret News archives:

Judge rejects Bluffdale land accord

Published: Friday, Nov. 11, 2005 9:54 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Just when Bluffdale city officials and developers thought they had reached a deal that would prevent 4,000 acres from leaving the city, a judge has nixed their agreement.

Third District Judge Anthony Quinn denied the proposed settlement agreement in the disconnection lawsuit brought by developers South Farm and Bluffdale Mountain Homes against the city, saying he was being asked to step into a political debate and make a planning and zoning decision outside the realm of the lawsuit.

"Courts generally avoid injecting themselves into political controversies," Quinn wrote in his order. "In this case, the proposed consent decree asks that I supplant the political process with respect to issues that are not even raised by the pleadings before me." And in the wake of this week's election shake-up, where the mayor was replaced by an anti-development candidate and two allied candidates won City Council seats, it looks like negotiations are over and the disconnection will go to trial.

"For us, we've worked on trying to work a plan with Bluffdale for 10 years now and finally came to an agreement, holding off on our disconnect to try and work it out yet once again," developer Jim Sorenson said. "We really don't have any choice at this point in time but to move forward with the disconnect now."

Story continues below
Speaking of the new mayor and council members, he said, "We really don't see this as a group that's interested in compromise."

The developers own land in southwestern Bluffdale, a rural chunk known as Area 4 that makes up about 40 percent of the city's land area. For years, the city and the developers have been haggling over plans for an extension of the Rosecrest development next door in Herriman.

The developers decided to seek disconnection — with the possibility of later annexing into Herriman's boundaries — after a December 2003 City Council decision that denied their application for a zoning change.

Since then, continued negotiations resulted in the city's creation of the so-called special development plan, a zoning category that would have allowed the city to deal with the land as a large parcel and begin negotiating the development specifics. But residents began a petition drive to put the SDP before a citywide vote, forming a group called Bluffdale United.

It was Bluffdale United that supported Claudia Anderson and council candidates Nancy Lord and Bill Maxwell, all of whom were elected Tuesday. It was also Bluffdale United that showed up in court late last month objecting to the proposed settlement.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Deseret Morning News graphic

previousnext

Latest comments

Congrats Rebels it was a great team effort, what is most impressive about...

TCU 55, Utah 28

Congratulations, TCU. Wyoming and New Mexico remain and anything can...

Oops he did it again. Barberi opens mouth, removes all doubt.

Byu makes me sick!

Name calling seems to be the depth of the debate for some. Please at least...

Famous WWI photo alerted world

The article was confusing, the writer needs to make sure his history and...

Soccer all-state honorable mention

We played against Riverton this year twice and they have a girl named Darian...

Presidential summits look good

happen as long as perverse socialist policies are the topic of the "summits"....

We own two of Fred Conlon little metal pieces that our children bought us for...

TCU creams U.

Ribbit Ribbit Ribbit Ribbit

Advertisements
Advertisement