From Deseret News archives:
Repeal criminal libel law
It would, admittedly, appear self-serving for a newspaper to advocate repealing a libel law. Our concern is on several levels, however.
First, the law does not pass constitutional muster. Libel is not the sole domain of traditional media organizations. The last Utahn prosecuted for criminal libel was a Milford High School student who maligned classmates and faculty members on a Web site. The teen was charged under an 1875 law enacted while Utah was a territory. In essence, the law said a person is guilty of libel if he "intentionally and with a malicious intent" publishes a statement impugning a person's honesty, integrity, virtue or reputation.
However, the U.S. Supreme Court in 1964 held that to hold the statement defamatory, it must be false and the person making it must know it's false or have a "reckless disregard" for whether it's true or not. The high court ruling rendered Utah's law unconstitutional, the state Supreme Court ruled.
Second, absent a criminal statute, Utahns still have the option of a civil libel action. That's how the Milford High case eventually played out. The high school principal sued the student and the case was settled. Seemingly, a civil action is a more appropriate remedy in these cases than criminalizing speech.
Beyond that, some media lawyers maintain that criminal libel and defamation laws have been abused, sometimes by prosecutors who have political motivations to file such charges.
From a practical standpoint, any law found unconstitutional should be stricken from the books. In fact, 33 states have repealed their criminal libel and defamation laws. It's time for Utah to do likewise.
Comments
- NHL roundup: Panthers tame Wild 8:46 p.m.
- Golf roundup: Tiger puts on a show 8:40 p.m.
- Cholesterol drugs under scrutiny 8:38 p.m.
- National news briefs 8:20 p.m.
- Big games keep UHSAA coffers full 8:19 p.m.
- 'Tweeters' to report on shuttle launch 8:18 p.m.
- Obama urges tough stance on Iran 8:18 p.m.
- Burned food sets off kitchen fire 8:06 p.m.
- Teams working to rescue lost hikers 8:06 p.m.
- Wounded Utes limp home 7:55 p.m.
- SLC council OKs gay rights policies
363 - BYU happy to escape with victory
228 - TCU creams U.
221 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights
203 - Will state consider gay rights law?
149 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
133 - Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?
131 - RSL heads to MLS title game
123 - Utes remain silent about BCS
120 - Celtics crush Jazz
104
Maybe someone out there can help me understand how raising the state...
TCU is good and with the weak teams that are ranked 5-10 there were they...
I have had a huge smile on my face all day from last night's game! I would...
Good Job, Springville. Sorry that you have to play Timpview at the state...
Just for discussion sake; what decisions that are made by the UHSAA are...
To Loose Moose, Um, let's see, BYU 7, TCU 38 on your home turf, with a...
It must have been cold there in our shadows Coog fans. And to think we...
TCU beat us. They are a better team this year. They beat BYU. They are a...
Isee today that BYU is 19 Utah is 22. HUH...what do you think of that?...
There are way too many cynical people who comment on these articles. Take...
How about we "restore" all of the sales tax and other exemptions given to...


You can be the first to comment on this story.