From Deseret News archives:

Immigration issues challenge Congress

Bush, GOP leaders vow to pass reform bill within year

Published: Friday, Oct. 14, 2005 10:54 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
When asked, "Do you favor or oppose a program that would allow undocumented immigrants now living in America to remain in the country and earn citizenship without penalty," 57 percent said they favored that while 39 percent opposed it.

No line jumping

Cannon said discussion among congressional members also indicates that most want to ensure reform will recognize that "being here illegally will not get you at the head of the line for citizenship over those who come later" legally.

In short, undocumented aliens would start at the back of the line whenever they come forward to seek legal status, but the sooner they do so, the farther in line they would be.

Also, Cannon said various steps are also being discussed that could help prevent giving welfare, government-paid health care or extra government services to temporary guest workers.

That includes, he said, looking at possibly requiring employers of "guest workers" to ensure they will have health insurance, or to require workers to have "health savings accounts." Cannon said that would cut down on complaints by some states and hospitals about spending on illegals and other immigrants.

Story continues below
(The Deseret Morning News/KSL-TV poll showed 79 percent feel illegals should receive emergency hospital care even if they do not have health insurance or cannot afford care. Twenty-six percent say the federal government should pay for it; 11 percent say the state should; 6 percent say hospitals should; and 26 percent said charities should.)

Cannon said reform may also include more sanctions against employers who do not pay Social Security taxes because that shows they know employees are illegal.

Cannon also expects reforms to address crime and lack of assimilation which he thinks is at the root of resentment by many anti-immigration groups.

"What we may do is end up revising the standards for citizenship," including having more consistent standards among states for how much English new citizens must speak and how well they understand the culture, he said. "I have known people who could not pass the English test in Utah and went to California because it was easier."

Cannon said, "If you want to be a citizen, you will likely have to go through a serious process. You will have to become American, not just be here. You will have to speak the language and learn how the culture works."

He expects that reform will require anyone wanting to enter or stay in the country to provide fingerprints, go through criminal background checks, and to prove over a long period that they are law abiding — or they would be deported quickly.

Reform smorgasbord

Cannon and Hatch note that myriad other reform ideas are floating around Congress, including some they are pushing themselves.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Luis Sanchez, Saturno/TH

A former school bus loaded with about 50 people now serves as transport for would-be migrants headed for the crossing point in Las Chepas, Mexico, south of New Mexico.

previousnext

Latest comments

There definetly is a chapel in center city philadelphia. I was there when it...

Oops - too late

The AP Top 25; TCU 4th, BYU 16

That BYU fans and players should now be rooting for a Utah bowl win so that...

Hall just said what Utah fans think and want to say about BYU. The only...

Sure Max Hall can say whatever he wants. But there's a way to say it with...

Fun game to watch from the stands. Always a bi-line associated with the game...

Hear ye, hear ye. Utah lost (again).

BYU and Utah are both good teams, as well as TCU. It's pretty funny and...

I hope all the BYU fans and all their hate and love of Max Hall had a good...

Hall mouths off about hate of Utah

I'd vote for him any day.

Advertisements