From Deseret News archives:
New tack on hate-crime law
Shurtleff proposes approach that dumps protected categories
Attorney General Mark Shurtleff is proposing a new approach that would remove protected categories that have repeatedly bogged down the legislation.
Last year's failed legislation would have stepped up penalties for crimes committed because of bias or prejudice against protected groups categorized by race, color, disability, religion, sexual orientation, national origin, ancestry, age and gender.
Some opposing legislators have said a crime is a crime, and that hate crimes legislation could hurt crime victims who don't fall in one of the listed categories.
"It's very clear it won't pass if we keep coming to the same list of categories," Shurtleff said.
Shurtleff declined to discuss details Thursday, saying he expected wording to be nailed down after a meeting of a working group this morning.
Litvack says he hasn't committed to Shurtleff's approach, but he's keeping an open mind. In the past, Litvack has refused to remove the categories.
Shurtleff said his proposal would give prosecutors and law enforcement the tools they need to charge a hate crime.
"I wouldn't be proposing it if I thought it watered it down," Shurtleff said.
A statewide coalition of law enforcement officers and prosecutors, including Shurtleff, say a 1992 law was stripped of its list of protected categories and is unenforceable, because it requires proving an intent to deprive someone of constitutional rights, in addition an intent to intimidate or terrorize. State and federal appeals courts have said the law is a civil rights statute, not a hate crimes law.
A working group of legal scholars, prosecutors and representatives of the Attorney General's Office has been discussing legislative possibilities since the close of the 2005 Legislature, Litvack said.
Shurtleff said the discussions included revamping language gleaned from a Georgia Supreme Court ruling that declared a hate crimes law without protected categories unconstitutionally vague.
"And that's where the questions come in: Is it enforceable? Constitutional? Does it provide the tool we need? Those are the questions we're still answering," Litvack said.
Shurtleff said the proposal has been looked at by Brigham Young University and University of Utah law professors and other scholars, who "think this proposal will pass constitutional muster." He's hoping it will also be palatable for a Republican co-sponsor.
Attempts to create what advocates call an enforceable hate crimes law began in the late 1990s by the late Sen. Pete Suazo, D-Salt Lake, and for the past five years has been unsuccessfully carried by Litvack.
E-mail: dbulkeley@desnews.com
Comments
- Tiger opens with a 66 in Australia 1:18 a.m.
- Crash kills Utah County man 1:12 a.m.
- UCAT cheaper education option 1:12 a.m.
- Post office to be named for Rex Lee 1:11 a.m.
- Police probe synagogue vandalism 1:09 a.m.
- New charges added in fraud case 1:09 a.m.
- Mom takes plea deal in girl's beating 1:08 a.m.
- Drug trafficking operation busted 1:07 a.m.
- News yule writing contest starting up 12:59 a.m.
- Alpine District school honored 12:59 a.m.
- SLC council OKs gay rights policies
- 'Love story' of crash victim ends
- Utah Jazz have a problem at point
- BYU football recruit turning heads
- Alta's Ohai is Ms. Soccer 2009
- Prep football: Felt's Facts Week
- 12 Utes return to Texas
- Cougars' defensive hoops clinic
- Long days for BYU interns
- Wyoming writer amazed by BYU
- House passes health care bill
287 - SLC council OKs gay rights policies
246 - TCU showdown has big implications
193 - Senators want food tax restored
157 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
155 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
131 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
119 - S.L. vote pending on gay protections
109 - Pratt pleads not guilty to sex charges
101 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
92
This week, I'm compiling my annual list of restaurants serving...
Beck, Hannity, and Limbaugh get the audience they deserve and vice versa. ...
I find the rule,very discriminitory. I am not gay, I don't understand what...
I understand we were outmanned last night. However, this effort was awful....
My advice to Jonathan is shoot it when they pass it to you as soon as you...
Maybe they should try drafting a shooting guard who can shoot from outside ....
The sad thing about it is that there are actually people out there that are...
Thank you TCU and BYU. Your wanting to beat Utah so bad has to drive you...
Play fes and koufos. Look to the future. It looks like we will have two...
Oh come on. Obama's a horrible president, but I couldn't care less which...
"We had the best soccer of any place in the state. There's no disputing...



You can be the first to comment on this story.