From Deseret News archives:

Bright students deserve more than busy work

Published: Wednesday, Sept. 14, 2005 7:05 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
If developing the high potential of some students wounds the "self-esteem" of other students, one obvious answer is for them to go their separate ways in different classrooms or different schools.

There was a time when students of different ability levels or performance levels were routinely assigned to different classes in the same grade or to different schools — and no one else collapsed like a house of cards because of wounded self-esteem.

Let's face it: Most of the teachers in our public schools do not have what it takes to develop high intellectual potential in students. They cannot give students what they don't have themselves.

Test scores going back more than half a century have repeatedly shown people who are studying to be teachers to be at or near the bottom among college students studying in various fields. It is amazing how often this plain reality gets ignored in discussions of what to do about our public schools.

Lack of competence is only part of the problem. Too often there is not only a lack of appreciation of outstanding intellectual development but a hostility towards it by teachers who are preoccupied with the "self-esteem" of mediocre students, who may remind them of what they were once like as students.

Story continues below
Maybe the advancement of science, of the economy, and finding a cure for cancer can wait, while we take care of self-esteem.


Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Regarding whether it was really Max's statement, or one supplied for him: Of...

Raymond is not a Mormon High School. It is a public high school with some...

Letters: Left-wing AP

'Now, care to provide a SINGLE QUOTE in which Rush, Sean, or Glenn encouraged...

2 citations issued at Y.-U. game

as a BYU fan be taking pictures of the Utah players? Shouldn't you be...

I was in the north end zone with most of the ute fans. I didn't see anything...

I feel there IS a difference between the tenor of the fans from Utah and...

2 citations issued at Y.-U. game

Yeah good luck with that. Didn't you read the comments prior to yours from...

6 sons soar as Eagle Scouts

Great Family! Great Values! We need more parents who are willing to put their...

2 citations issued at Y.-U. game

So what do you have to say to the BYU fan that hit Jamie Whittingham in the...

The cellphone/camera-hating guy sounds really unstable. Someone should taze...

Advertisements