From Deseret News archives:

Utah using new approach on polygamy

Sunstone speaker says law and safety net to deal with issue

Published: Friday, July 29, 2005 11:55 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The Sunstone Symposium program frames the question this way: How is the state of Utah dealing with contemporary polygamy?

The answer is: Differently than ever before, Utah Attorney General Office spokesman Paul Murphy says.

Raids on the families of Short Creek in 1953 — an area known today as the border towns of Hildale, Utah, and Colorado City, Ariz. — were a mistake, Murphy said. But the state's decision to ignore those communities for the 50 years that followed "was an even bigger mistake," he adds.

These days the attorney general's approach is two-pronged.

"There's the law enforcement track and the safety net track," Murphy explains, adding that both require — and have had — the active involvement of many practicing polygamists.

"It is no longer us talking about them and them talking about us," Murphy said, recounting a discussion with a polygamist woman with whom he consults. "It's about all of us coming together and trying to come up with solutions."

Story continues below
Murphy's remarks were made Friday during a breakout session of the annual symposium in Salt Lake City. The three-day event is sponsored by the Sunstone Foundation, an organization founded in 1974 as an open forum for the discussion of spiritual, intellectual, historical and cultural issues associated with Mormon life.

Once a principal tenet of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the church abandoned the practice of plural marriage more than 100 years ago as Utah sought statehood.

But several sects of believers — today often referred to as fundamentalists — refused to abandon the practice and continue to believe that it is a cornerstone of their eternal salvation.

Utah authorities have paid frenetic attention to the issue, sometimes actively seeking to arrest and prosecute members of various polygamous sects, or conversely ignoring them.

Beginning in the mid-1990s a handful of criminal prosecutions raised awareness about acts of child abuse, domestic violence and fraud occurring among some groups. That prompted Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff to seek ways to address the problem.

His two-track approach is designed to tackle real crime and give social support to women and children without persecuting religious beliefs, Murphy said.

A working group of practicing polygamists — mostly women — law enforcement and social workers has produced training classes and a manual for understanding the polygamist culture and the unique problems that those seeking help or leaving their communities face.

"We want to make sure the folks in those communities have equal access to justice and services," Murphy said. "Are we doing enough? Of course not."

Session moderator Anne Wilde, who helped organize the pro-plural marriage group Principle Voice of Polygamy, said the attorney general's approach is progress because the office has listened to the polygamist point of view.

"We've said do nothing about us, without us," Wilde said. "People are listening for the first time."

Murphy believes the cooperation presents a historic opportunity.

"Everyone is hopeful about what can be accomplished," he said. "And everyone is fearful about what will happen if we fail."

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I am trully saddened by the racist and bigoted remarks here. Utah really...

Hey Anon, Ms. is short for Miss genius Also, her dad was at Cottonwood and...

What happened to the Republican motto "lower taxes, lower taxes" we should...

amen Murray skeptic it is the fad in Murray, I am worried about a Ukrainian...

TO those liberals who are buying into the government takeover of health...

In st george there are already lots of people who go to mesquite to shop and...

Matheson gets no thanks from GOP

Kudos to Matheson. Unlike the President and most of his party, he understands...

"McIff says the food tax cut really didn't help low-income Utahns that much,...

'We all ready have discrimination law.' And it is still legal to fire &...

City staff says the city will make money. Yeah, and Obama's health care...

Advertisements
Advertisement