From Deseret News archives:

Strip clubs, escort service set to renew legal battle over tax

Published: Thursday, July 14, 2005 8:46 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Strip clubs and an escort service are stepping up a challenge to a special tax levied by the Utah Legislature a year ago.

Many clubs and escort services have gotten away with not charging the 10 percent tax amid lax state enforcement, and objections to the tax are now headed back to a state district court.

Sex-industry lobbyist and lawyer Andrew McCullough said Thursday he was renewing a legal battle by filing a motion for a preliminary injunction against the cover-charge tax.

McCullough said one of his clients, the strip club American Bush, has been paying the tax in order to challenge it, but that many other clubs in Utah are refusing to collect it.

McCullough said he doesn't know of any escort service that's adding the tax to customers' bills. The tax is in addition to the income and sales taxes the businesses already pay.

The tax was supposed to raise $1 million a year for treatment of sex offenders, but the first year's take was less than $5,000, said Tax Commissioner Palmer DePaulis.

"We have not been pressing this until we get done with the litigation," DePaulis said Thursday.

Story continues below
Originally a state judge ruled McCullough's suit was out of his jurisdiction and a matter for the Tax Commission to adjudicate. But the industry's appeal to the Utah Court of Appeals bounced the case back to 3rd District Judge Tyrone Medley for resolution.

McCullough plans to file his motion with Medley as early as Friday, renewing the suit by Salt Lake County strip clubs the Crazy Goat Saloon, Northern Exposure, Southern Exposure, American Bush, Trails and Trails II. Joining them was Companions Escorts.

Some Utah legislators didn't want to tax an industry they said they couldn't condone — one called it "dirty money." And it wasn't one of Utah's socially conservative Republicans who sponsored the tax, it was a Democrat.

The sponsor, Rep. Duane Bourdeaux, D-Salt Lake City, disclosed a conflict of interest as executive director of the Center for Family Development, which treats sex offenders at prison halfway houses. Bourdeaux said he expected to benefit from some of the tax proceeds.

Bourdeaux defended the tax by saying the state had a compelling interest in fighting the "secondary" effects that strip clubs have on customers.

Legislative attorneys warned that singling out strip clubs and escort businesses with a special tax could land the state in court accused of violating the Constitution's equal protection clause or the First Amendment.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I can't wait to get my free lunch. Subsidized health insurance with all the...

Utahns want health care reform bills

I am retired now and for the last 15 years of my employment my employer was...

Andrew George has cemented his BYU Legacy into the history books and Y fans...

TRAX is great! But for SLC and the Wasatch Front to be considered world...

Letters: Look to the coach

Personal fouls are taken care of right on the field. (Don't you wish our...

Yes, BYU attendee -Congratulations is in order. But remember what Mark Twain...

Beware delusions on climate

When you have nothing intelligent to say, attack the messenger. Likewise for...

Thanks for the info, but I must be a slow learner! So here we are, all of us...

Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing

I watch Beck and there are things I like and things I don't like. The whole...

2nd gay bishop is elected

Episcopalians take the Bible every bit as seriously as you do - they just...

Advertisements