From Deseret News archives:

Endangered Utah flower gets its very own lawsuit

Published: Wednesday, July 6, 2005 9:09 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
BIRDSEYE, Utah County — A resident of this small town recently became the subject of a national lawsuit.

The target is not a militiaman or a polygamist, or any of the other usual controversial figures that frequent rural Utah. It's a shrubby, endangered flower with a strange name, the Deseret milk-vetch.

The lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C. by the Utah Native Plant Society, the Center for Native Ecosystems and Forest Guardians. The suit requests that the Department of the Interior make the Utah Fish and Wildlife Service designate a critical habitat to protect the flower and develop a recovery plan to help it proliferate.

"What's basically prompting this lawsuit is that no recovery plan has been adopted and we're basically running out of time," said Tony Frates, of the Utah Native Plant Society.

The Deseret milk-vetch, or Astragalus desereticus, is known to grow in only one place in the world, an area of slightly less than 300 acres near U.S. 89 between Birdseye and Thistle. The groups who filed the lawsuit say urban sprawl in the area and the possible expansion of the highway pose a critical threat to the survival of the species and action must be taken.

Story continues below
And while officials from wildlife services agree that the flower needs to be protected, they say the situation is not as urgent as the lawsuit indicates.

"It's all just potential," said Larry England, a botanist for the agency. "Our concern for this species has been superseded by concerns for other species that are in greater danger. We do not see a great urgency (in this case)."

When the Deseret milk-vetch was placed on the endangered list in 1999, England said wildlife services decided not to designate the area as a critical habitat for the flower (as the lawsuit requests) because doing so would offer no real additional protection.

"When the flower was listed, we considered a critical habitat was not necessary for the conservation of the species," he said. "We're working on a recovery plan for the flower, and we'd like to have it done sooner than later."

Frates said he doesn't believe the agency has been criminally negligent in its treatment of the flower, but it should have done a better job by establishing a critical habitat.

"(The Deseret milk-vetch) has definitely suffered some neglect, but it's not willful or wanton neglect," he said.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Tony Frates, UNPS

The Deseret milk-vetch, or Astragalus desereticus, grows only in an area near Birdseye, Utah County.

previousnext

Latest comments

Congrats. Let's hope the team is ready to play and not content to go through...

High school track results

Riverton throwers keep win them every meet. They have the best throwing coach...

Thank you for the facts, Mr. Jarvis, and I agree with you about George Will.

It's typical. Here this wonderful thing happened and all you guys can talk...

So Senator McCoy wants Matheson's seat. That's understandable. It has to be...

Party insiders may take on Bennett

Bennett's lips may draw near to the Constitution, but his heart is far from...

I think non-mormon is either Mr. Ash himself or a strong supporter just...

Jazz blow big lead, hang on

Reports are all out tonight about my good friend (not) "Nellie" Stephen...

CFL legend prefers sacrament to slotback

I loved watching Ben at BYU. I remember yelling in the stands "It's 3rd & Ben...

It is sad that just because you can not see, feel or understand something...

Advertisements
Advertisement