From Deseret News archives:

Utahn's move to bench certain?

Published: Friday, May 27, 2005 11:47 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — With a truce now in place between warring partisans on Senate filibusters, Utahn Tom Griffith should be confirmed to the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for Washington, D.C., in the next few days.

"But there are lots of traps and snares, and I won't be happy until it is through," said Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, who has worked behind the scenes to bolster support when it appeared the nomination was slipping away. "There is still a lot of bitterness, and there are no sure things."

Griffith's nomination to what is considered to be the second most powerful court in the nation had become bogged down amid the controversy over the use of the filibuster by minority Democrats to thwart President Bush's judicial nominations they considered too conservative or too controversial.

Republicans had threatened the so-called "nuclear" or "constitutional" option to break the filibusters — a changing of the rules so that the 56-44 Republican majority could cut off debate with a 51-vote majority rather than the current 60 votes needed.

A deal between moderates on both sides, announced Monday night, calls for up or down votes on three of the most controversial nominees but not certain others, and a pledge that Democrats will use the filibuster only in the most extreme cases.

Story continues below
That deal opens the door for votes this week on judicial nominees like Griffith, the current general counsel at Brigham Young University who is opposed by many Democrats but is not among the controversial nominees subject to the filibusters.

Griffith can probably blame Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., for the delayed vote. Reid had stated that Democrats would not filibuster Griffith as a show of good faith during negotiations with the majority over the nuclear option — even though Democrats had some serious problems with Griffith.

According to Hatch, Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., wasn't about to have Harry Reid decide which of the nominees was going to "go first."

Frist had already decided the nomination of Priscilla R. Owen of Texas would go first. Owen was confirmed Wednesday by a 56-43 vote, the first beneficiary of the filibuster truce.

"The deal appears to be a positive step, but only time will tell," Hatch said of the deal. "But this is a truce, not a treaty."

And, he adds, Republicans are watching closely, expecting Democrats' definition of "extreme circumstances" will evolve to where they invoke the filibuster on just about anyone who is conservative.

"Any party that will call Patricia Owen a Neanderthal and extreme is going to call anyone Neanderthal and extreme," he said. "She is as reasonable and decent as a person can be."

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

Tom Griffith

previousnext

Latest comments

All lawyer/legal tactics aside, there are only three ultimate possibilities:...

"I read they do like people w/ accounting degrees and/or people of the LDS...

Utah man dies in Oregon crash

God was only aiming for one of us. The rest of us have minor bumps bruises,...

Welcome sir ! You're extremely important to all of us ! Thank you for your...

FBI names new Salt Lake office head

Welcome to the Salt Lake City Field Office Mr. McTighe. Maybe we'll get some...

Baby-bottle dangers

Interesting article, but don't understand the danger of non carbon receipts....

Letters: A poisonous potion

The "progressives" and "liberals" who think that the Constitution has no...

Utah Jazz: Miles has cast removed

Soon we will see if CJ is as good as you think he is?? I'm not sure he would...

That's kind of the point. Most people don't mind Bingham or Alta saying they...

JD you and your school SS are nothing but losers! your season is over!!!!!!...

Advertisements
Advertisement