Any state tax reform that junks the current charitable deduction on personal income taxes will have a tough time passing the Legislature, leaders said Friday in reaction to a statement by the LDS Church on Thursday. The statement opposed doing away with the longtime deduction.

The church's opposition — and likely forthcoming opposition by other religious and charitable organizations — will have a "strong dampening effect" on any push for a true flat-rate income tax, said House Speaker Greg Curtis, R-Sandy.

Senate President John Valentine, R-Orem, said he anticipates other "religious entities and organizations will also speak out on this," and that the combined voices "will have an impact on the debate over doing away" with the charitable deduction.

"The LDS Church may be the first to speak out," said Valentine, a tax attorney, "but we will hear from others, including the financial community, on the idea of doing away with the deduction for primary residences' mortgage interest."

Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. still thinks the flat tax should be debated by the task force.

"We're still anxious that a flat income tax rate be on the table for discussion. We think it's a concept that's very worthy of consideration," said the governor's legislative liaison, Mike Mower. "It will be one of many proposals that will be considered over the next few months."

Mower declined to comment on whether the LDS Church opposition makes that less likely, saying only that the governor is "anxious for all interested Utahns to be involved in the discussions on tax policy."

The state's Tax Reform Task Force is considering all kinds of tax reform issues through this summer and fall, including a flat-rate income tax. A "pure" flat-rate tax has no personal exemptions or deductions. In hearings Thursday, the task force heard that Utah's top income tax rate — 7 percent — could be lowered to 4 percent if a pure flat rate system was adopted.

Task force members are scheduled to make at least some recommendations to the governor and the 2006 Legislature in January.

Asked to comment on the idea of doing away with all deductions on state personal income taxes, Dale Bills, a spokesman for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, issued the following statement Thursday evening:

"The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints acknowledges the thoughtful efforts of many in the state government to review Utah's tax structure. For the overall good of the citizenry, the state tax system should continue to provide tax deductions for charitable giving — including religious contributions. Charitable contributions help provide for society's poor and needy, education and the arts, and other important social needs."