From Deseret News archives:

Weighty issues await the Supreme Court

Rehnquist's future may be the biggest question of all

Published: Thursday, May 12, 2005 11:45 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — Highly anticipated decisions on medical marijuana, Ten Commandments displays and Internet sharing of movies and music are still to come in the final weeks of the Supreme Court term.

And then there's perhaps the biggest story of all — whether the court gets its first opening in a decade.

Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, 80, has been the focus of retirement speculation since he announced in October that he had thyroid cancer.

Rehnquist has been working full-time and has given no indication of his plans, though most court watchers believe he will step down. His departure likely would lead to a political fight over a successor who could reshape a court divided 5-4 on the death penalty, affirmative action and gay rights.

The court's opinions already are giving partisans plenty to talk about.

"This term will be a blockbuster," said Tom Goldstein, a Washington lawyer who argues frequently before the high court. "The court's rulings on social issues and the role of government will definitely remind everyone of the significance of a single Supreme Court appointment."

Story continues below
The court already has issued two of its more notable rulings — 5-4 opinions striking down mandatory sentencing guidelines as a violation of a defendant's right to a jury trial and outlawing the death penalty for those who were juveniles when they committed their crimes.

While the death penalty ruling was somewhat expected given earlier rulings narrowing the scope of capital punishment, some congressional Republicans blasted the opinion by Justice Anthony Kennedy for citing international sentiment against executing juveniles. House Majority Leader Tom DeLay, R-Texas, condemned the Reagan appointee's work as "incredibly outrageous," and others called for his impeachment.

May and June traditionally are the court's busiest months and this year is no different. There are 35 opinions remaining before justices take a summer break.

One of the most closely watched decisions involves whether states can shield medical marijuana users from federal prosecution on drug charges. The case, which was heard last November, pits the conservative anti-drug interests of the Bush administration against conservative principles of states' rights.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Eric, When one of your kids refuses to do his weekly chores, and your...

Obama tells banks to lend more

are holding the prospect of mandatory insurance and the "cap and tax" schemes...

Mink vandal says feds broke deal

Getalife seems to have the habit of taking the brake of his mouth before...

@ 9:57 "But when Sarah up and quit as governer, with no real justification...

Jazz stunned by Timberwolves

for not running the offense and not rebounding. However, the coaches are at...

How come BSU and Utah fans join with BYU and other "non AQ" team fans and...

region 15 is clearly the true class of 1a look at the final standings the...

T-WOLVES....LAST team of the WEST....HOW????? AT HOME....WITH EVERY PLAYER!!!

Top 20 boys basketball

Why does your Top 25 have only 20 teams?

Hold on everyone we are officially in the twilight zone. Will the court soon...

Advertisements