From Deseret News archives:

Friend or foe? Wal-Mart alters Utah landscape

Convenience and low prices often win over staunchest foes

Published: Sunday, March 27, 2005 12:28 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Janet Mortenson doesn't sugarcoat it — she hates Wal-Mart.

She hates the crowded aisles, long checkout lines and stacks of merchandise at "everyday low prices."

But most of all she hates the retailer for putting her wholesale shop out of business. One by one, Rainbow Crafts' loyal customer base was sucked away as clients' rural stores closed in the shadow of Utah's retail giant: Wal-Mart.

"When a Wal-Mart goes into a small town, it affects so many people," said Mortenson, whose Salt Lake store served clients throughout the state. "The chains just seem to be getting bigger and bigger, and the independents are folding right and left."

Some see it as David vs. Goliath. Others use stronger language, pegging it as good vs. evil.

But no matter how defined, it is a battle waged in cities across Utah and across the nation: the battle of the big box.

At the core of the conundrum stands Wal-Mart with its concrete walls and sprawling parking lots. The store's reputation for crushing local shops has many Utah residents up in arms when the retail tycoon comes knocking.

Story continues below
But soon after, fears seem to fade. In areas where residents once rallied en masse against a new Wal-Mart, shoppers jockey for parking spaces.

Despite recent opposition by residents in Sandy, Riverton, Ogden and Centerville, Wal-Marts continue to pop up around Utah, with nine added in 2004 and at least four more set to be built soon. Low prices and convenience win over the store's staunchest opposition, said James Wood, director of the University of Utah Bureau of Economic Research.

"Even though you might be supporting exploitation in China and rotten wages, people still are moved by their own pocketbook. They know that going in," he said.

Wood is now studying that Wal-Mart paradox, trying to determine how a city changes in the wake of the big-box store.

It's a study that prompts the question: Will Wal-Mart bring traffic and blight to cities, or can the store breathe new life into struggling economies?

Paying the price

A Deseret Morning News/KSL-TV poll found 55 percent of Utahns would welcome a Wal-Mart in their city or town, even though 87 percent of respondents also said big-box retailers hurt local business. The poll, conducted Nov. 29-30, surveyed 313 residents and has a 6.5 percent margin of error.

Eric Berger, Wal-Mart regional spokesman, said the retailer has generally been well-received in Utah despite concerns about traffic and noise.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Deseret Morning News graphic

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

Wildcats dangerous foe for Utes

Every team is a dangerous foe for utah this year.

My Apology for missing the decimal place. In an earlier comment, I stated...

Wall Street needs 12-step program

During most of the "drunk" period, the Fed was run by Allan Greenspan who...

NFL locals watch

Isn't it amazing that Austin Collie is closer to a Super Bowl ring than Alex...

Mike Lee isn't even in the race (maybe he will) and is only 2% behind a...

Max Hall: a fixture in rivalry lore

We all have our favorite phrases to sum up the TDS - Utah rivalry games....

Then it was also a tie game in 2005.

Letters: Acceptable CO2 level?

Re: "Even if the danger is overstated, we need to be better stewards of the...

I suppose all of you that feel his actions are justified because of his...

When someone gets HIV because they had a blood transfusion, or married to...

Advertisements