From Deseret News archives:
Fluoride group wants Davis to pay legal fees
Appeals court considering argument for exception
The pro-fluoride group took their case to the Utah Court of Appeals on Tuesday, arguing that because they fought to uphold the will of the majority of Davis voters, who voted by a narrow margin in 2000 for water fluoridation, they qualify for a rare exception in the law to allow their fees to be paid by the government.
Because Davis County's attorney, clerk and commission chair were in support of seeking yet another voter initiative to overturn the 2000 decision, "the majority of Davis County voters were left on their own to vindicate their rights," said Utahns for Better Dental Health attorney David Irvine during oral arguments before the court.
Typically in legal cases, each party pays for their respective legal costs, unless a judge finds special circumstances to require a party to pay the other's fees. Irvine said under the "private attorney general doctrine" his group deserves to have the $45,034 in legal costs paid for by the county.
With Davis officials taking an anti-fluoride stance, there was no one to champion the pro-fluoride cause, Irvine said.
"The voters had their own taxes used against them to fund an attack by the minority against the will of the majority, leaving only a few private citizens who were willing to challenge the government's errors," Irvine wrote in his brief to the court.
A 2nd District judge ruled that the group was not entitled to their fees being paid, which the group now appeals.
David Thompson, attorney for Davis County, argued that Judge Glen Dawson was within his discretion to deny the request.
The decision hinges upon a 1994 case in which a group sued the Utah Public Service Commission over a move by Qwest to raise phone rates. Although the group lost, the Utah Supreme Court found that they had "vindicated" a public cause and awarded attorney's fees. However, the high court ruled that such awards could only take place in extraordinary circumstances.
Dawson ruled that while Utahns for Better Dental Health did vindicate a cause, their victory did not lead to a monetary gain for the public; therefore, they did not deserve such an award.
Some justices said they were troubled by the fact that Dawson had noted their public cause but had ruled against their request. Justice Judith Billings said she felt this may have a "chilling result" for groups who take up a public cause.
The court is expected to issue a ruling in the following weeks.
Thompson said the only way the appellate court can award attorney's fees is if they find that Dawson "abused his discretion."
E-mail: gfattah@desnews.com
Comments
- Steelers lead Broncos at halftime 8:13 p.m.
- Jazz win in N.Y. for 1st time since '04 8:02 p.m.
- Suns outlast 76ers, 119-115 7:51 p.m.
- Quilt auction aims to benefit lives 7:44 p.m.
- Eating fruit not a cause of weight gain 7:44 p.m.
- Charcoal, cat-box filler help with odors 7:44 p.m.
- Wife and friend are too close 7:44 p.m.
- 'Brain' seems scattered 7:44 p.m.
- Locklear at 'Melrose Place' again 7:44 p.m.
- Tuesday on TV 7:44 p.m.
- TCU showdown has big implications
- Seniors helped BYU regroup
- Lambert surprisingly tops news
- Hope for single moms
- Bystanders framed for child porn
- Korver and Miles to be evaluated
- Prep girls soccer MVPs named
- Utah Jazz Extra: Whose hot/not
- GOP blasts Matheson after vote
- Newhouse Hotel, an explosive end
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
269 - House passes health care bill
224 - Lobo suspended
180 - TCU showdown has big implications
175 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
154 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
131 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
112 - Thousands protest health bill
110 - RSL rallies to advance
103 - No 'backlash' for pioneers, gays analogy
94
Meghan McCain, the daughter of former presidential candidate John...
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
It's a start in the right direction, maybe just have the UTE v. BYU game held...
We cannot overlook the performance of a man who did not diminish in any other...
I WENT TO THE SNOW GAME THERE LAST YEAR AND IT WAS GOOD TO BAD THEY LOST......
"Overall, however, I think he was one of our most gifted presidents in terms...
I'm conservative, but I like Matheson. A lot. Standing up to your own party...
If a Local Newspaper thinks it's news, THEN IT IS NEWS at least to the local...
When was the last time the art dept at the u of u earned 15million dollars...
Byu is Fooder for he Horned Frogs and the Utes. Your only prupose in this...
IM A HUGH UTES FAN! WOULD LOVE TO SEE UTAH BEAT TCU BUT I DOUBT IT WILL...
"the free market solve the health care problem" Are you kidding me? In what...


You can be the first to comment on this story.