From Deseret News archives:

GOP kills airing of minority reports

Published: Thursday, Feb. 24, 2005 8:38 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
On a straight party line vote Thursday, GOP House members effectively killed the ability — admittedly rarely used — for Democrats to have a minority committee report read on the House floor or printed in the official journal.

Both Republicans and Democrats said that anyone, or any group, of House members could write a dissenting report to a standing committee's action on a bill. And that's true. But the reality is that when three Democrats had a minority report read in the first week of the session, criticizing HJR1 (a resolution on the controversial bank/credit union fight), majority Republicans quickly acted to kill first the report and then change internal rules so such an action won't happen again.

Rep. Dave Ure, R-Kamas, sponsored HR7, which at first said only the names of dissenting minority members would be included in the official report from a committee action. But even that was too much publicity for any naysayers. His resolution was changed to say minority report members names wouldn't be included.

Rep. Neil Hansen, D-Ogden, then tried to amend HR7 so that a minority report would be in the journal or, failing that, at least printed and attached to the official "blue-back" copy of the bill advanced against a minority's desire. Republicans also killed that idea.

Story continues below
Free speech by any legislator won't be harmed, Rep. Dave Cox, R-Lehi, reminded the House. When any bill is debated on the floor, those in the committee who voted against it can stand and state their reasons, even read a written statement again to a minority report if they wish.

While that's true, individual lawmakers' statements are not recorded verbatim in the journal nor connected in any official way with a bill as it proceeds.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Four elements out of a 2100 page bill: That's some realistic polling. A...

BYU 26-utah 23. Utah state = after thought.

I'm not worried about your first admendment rights. But I sure wish you would...

Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing

What's dumb about the title to this article is that Glenn Beck doesn't speak...

Utah Jazz: Wolves get past Jazz

Greg Oden suffered a serious knee injury. His season if not career could be...

Charities are not costing the U.S. anything! The money American citizens...

Yeah it's almost 2010 but I still get hungry and I still want to eat. If that...

would not accept a bid to the silly Maaco bowl in lousy las vegas would they?...

Highland may pay for burned home

This is all we need is more people telling someone what to do with their own...

Utes stop Idaho State

home games does utah get? Go Vandals!

Advertisements