From Deseret News archives:

Bigamy law debated

Justices ask if statute should be used to prosecute polygamists

Published: Thursday, Feb. 3, 2005 11:41 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Justices with the Utah Supreme Court questioned Thursday whether state prosecutors should use Utah's bigamy statute to go after polygamists — a key law used to go after those who practice the controversial way of life.

Justices have also called into question whether the passage in Utah's constitution banning polygamy, should be revisited, given modern changes in attitudes toward various kinds of sexual relationships.

In a lengthy hearing, the attorney for former Hildale police officer Rodney Holm, who was prosecuted for taking his 16-year-old sister-in-law as his third "spiritual" wife, argued before the state's high court that prosecutors are selectively targeting polygamists using the bigamy statute because of their religious beliefs.

"Non-religious actors are not targeted by law enforcement by this law," said attorney Rodney Parker, pointing to the various residents who live in non-married relationships. "Holm is not seeking legal recognition of his relationship or change the institution of marriage."

Parker said Holm, who is a member of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints — a polygamist group lead by Warren Jeffs — believes it is his constitutional right to practice his religion, which includes plural marriage.

Story continues below
The 32-year-old officer took his 16-year-old sister-in-law, Ruth Stubbs, as his third wife in December 1998. Holm was eventually convicted in 2003 on two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor and one count of bigamy.

Assistant Attorney General Laura Dupaix argued it was clear, in the Utah Supreme Court's own ruling in the appeal of polygamist Tom Green, that those who try to establish a "marital" relationship with more than one person run afoul of Utah's bigamy statute.

However, justices said the biggest difference between Green and Holm was that Green was found to have been legally married to two women at the same time. In Holm's case, he never sought a legal marriage with Stubbs, although he was legally married to his first wife, justices noted.

Prosecutors have used Utah's bigamy statute to prosecute those who practice plural marriage. Utah's bigamy law uses cohabitation, or living together as husband and wife, as a standard for prosecution. Three other states, Rhode Island, Colorado and Texas, have similar laws.

However, Chief Justice Christine Durham said simply living together does not constitute a crime. Durham also cited the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling, Lawrence vs. Texas, which struck down the state's sodomy laws, as evidence that the state cannot regulate private sexual relationships.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

Rod and Suzie Holm leave court in St. George in 2002. He was prosecuted for taking his 16-year-old sister-in-law as his third "spiritual" wife.

previousnext

Latest comments

How do these tell all books help the family. Children need to be protected...

Suicide attackers kill 35 at mosque

...probably justify their actions by claiming that they are acting on THEIR...

Letters: Don't dump primary

Thanks for your insightful letter. As a former Republican, you are correct...

It is an honor to be mentione as a finalist. The other finalists put him in...

Haven't you heard...Money in the pockets of politicians from people seeking...

You will be the President of the U.S in 2012. We give you more than 100%...

HD helped The mtn. immensely

The Mtn is not a real network until it is on Dishnetwork as well as Direct TV.

I am a big fan of The Alan Parsons Project. This is sad news.

Letters: Bikers need safe place

Why does society have to provide you with a safe quiet place to ride? I own...

Isn't it interesting that Tiger is the most recognized athlete in the world,...

Advertisements